Ball lightning
What is ball lightning?
Summary
Why it is open
Ball lightning has many eyewitness reports but competing physical explanations [8, 10]. What is known of its features comes mainly from eyewitnesses [8]. Jianyong Cen and colleagues summarise reports of near-ground luminous balls during thunderstorms, typically 1–100 cm across and lasting 1–10 seconds [8]. Some reports describe balls forming inside houses and aircraft cockpits [7], or passing through closed glass windows [10].
Many models have been proposed [8, 10]. In 2000 John Abrahamson and James Dinniss wrote that none had explained all of the observed characteristics [1], and in 2016 H.-C. Wu wrote that none had been fully accepted [10]. The models divide according to whether the ball's energy is stored inside it or supplied from outside [8].
It may also be several problems. Cen and colleagues note that the range of reported characteristics allows more than one type of ball lightning and more than one mechanism [8]; some reports may describe a perception rather than an object [5, 6]; and laboratory experiments "may not bear any relation to ball lightning formation in the natural environment", the science writer Philip Ball noted in 2014 [9].
Instrumental records of natural events are scarce [8, 9], and in the view of the lightning specialist Martin Uman what appears to be the first recorded spectrum does not show which theory is correct [9].
What is known
Eyewitness reports. Ball lightning has been reported for centuries [1], and Wu bases his list of its properties on about 5,000 published sighting reports [10]. A 2002 collection by Abrahamson, A. V. Bychkov and V. L. Bychkov assembled letters and interviews, many from scientifically or technically trained observers [2]. J. J. Lowke and colleagues describe two cases in which aircraft navigation crews saw a ball form at the windscreen inside the cockpit, and one at a closed window in a house during a thunderstorm [7]. Cen and colleagues provide an instrumental example with video and spectra [8].
Reports as perceptions. Gerald and Vernon Cooray compared ball lightning reports with the symptoms of seizures in the occipital lobe, the brain's visual area, and calculated that the changing magnetic field near an intense lightning flash is strong enough to stimulate neurons [5]. J. Peer and A. Kendl compared the fields of long lightning discharges with those of transcranial magnetic stimulation and proposed this as a plausible interpretation of a large class of reports of luminous perceptions during thunderstorms; a correction later in 2010 found the induced fields more than an order of magnitude smaller for average lightning, and concluded that stimulation of the retina, not the visual cortex, is the most probable case [6].
The 2012 recording. On 23 July 2012, while recording spectra of ordinary lightning on the Qinghai Plateau in China with two slitless spectrographs (cameras with a grating that spreads light into a spectrum), Cen, Ping Yuan and Simin Xue recorded a ball that formed at the bottom of a cloud-to-ground lightning channel about 0.9 km away [8]. It glowed for 1.64 s and moved at an apparent 8.6 m/s; its roughly 5 m luminous extent did not establish the object's real diameter [8]. Emission lines of neutral silicon, iron and calcium, main components of soil, were present throughout, while nitrogen and oxygen lines rose and fell with the light intensity, which oscillated at 99.4 Hz [8]. High-voltage lines ran about 20 m away, and the authors suggest that the oscillation is possibly a second-harmonic effect of their 50 Hz frequency [8]. They stress that this is "only one event that may not be representative of all ball lightning" [8]. Uman called it "probably of ball lightning, or one type of ball lightning" [9].
Laboratory analogues. Electric arcs in pure silicon produce luminous balls that last seconds and share "several properties usually reported for natural ball lightning" [4]. Localised microwaves create a molten hot spot in silicon, glass, basalt and other solids, from which a buoyant fireball is ejected [3].
Recent claims. In April 2026 Chuliang Zhou and colleagues, at institutions including the Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics, reported in Nature Photonics a soliton, a stable lump of electromagnetic energy [13], made by focusing a femtosecond laser on a tungsten tip in an argon jet [12]. The millimetre-scale object lasted 100 ns in argon; the authors propose scaling it to natural conditions, rather than reporting a seconds-long atmospheric event [12]. The summary line of a News & Views article by Sergei Bulanov in the same journal says the experiments indicate that such solitons "could indeed explain the phenomenon" [13].
Main approaches
Burning soil. When lightning strikes soil, nanoparticles of silicon, silicon monoxide or silicon carbide are thrown into the air as a filamentary network, and their slow oxidation releases the stored energy as heat and light [1]. Strongest evidence: the soil elements in the 2012 spectrum [8], about which Uman said: "This one certainly seems to be made of dirt" [9]; chains of nanoparticles from discharges into soil samples that oxidise at a rate matching ball lightning lifetimes [1]; and silicon balls in the laboratory [4]. Main difficulty: the spectrum is one event [8], and Wu writes that earlier theories do not explain balls inside fully screened aircraft [10].
Trapped electromagnetic energy. Ball lightning is a plasma bubble holding intense microwaves; in P. L. Kapitsa's model, the best known of its kind according to Cen and colleagues, an intense radio-frequency field supplies the energy [8]. Wu proposes that a bunch of relativistic electrons from the lightning leader generates the microwaves when it strikes the ground or passes through an aircraft's skin [10]. Strongest evidence: particle simulations in which the microwaves trap themselves in a stable bubble about 24 cm across; Wu's account also covers balls inside aircraft, passage through glass and the 100 Hz modulation in the 2012 spectrum [10]; and the 2026 laboratory soliton, which shows that a relativistic electromagnetic soliton can be made at millimetre scale [12, 13]. Main difficulty: the electron bunch is an assumption, and Wu's 2016 estimate required hundreds of gigawatts, beyond the sources he considered [10]; the laboratory soliton lasted 100 ns, in argon [12].
Charge on windows. For balls inside rooms and cockpits, atmospheric ions collect on the outside of insulating glass or Perspex windows, opposite charge gathers on the inside, and a ball of net charge drives a pulsed discharge [7]. Strongest evidence: three eyewitness cases, two of them from aircrews [7]. Main difficulty: beyond those cases, the support is two-dimensional calculations of ion and electron transport [7].
Perception. Some reports describe sensations caused by a seizure or by lightning fields acting on the eye or brain, not objects [5, 6]. Strongest evidence: the comparisons with seizure symptoms and with magnetic stimulation [5, 6]. Main difficulty: after the 2010 correction, even stronger than average lightning gives fields above the threshold for stimulating the visual cortex only within metres of the strike, or at about 50 m only for pulses shorter than axon excitation periods [6], and the account does not apply to the instrumental event recorded by Cen and colleagues [8].
Open sub-questions
- More spectra. Do spectra of other natural events show silicon, iron and calcium lines throughout, as in 2012, or only lines from air [8]?
- The 100 Hz signal. In events far from power lines, or near 60 Hz grids, does the periodic nitrogen and oxygen emission disappear or shift to 120 Hz, as a power-line cause implies [8, 10]?
- Microwaves at strike points. Do GHz receivers near cloud-to-ground strike points record the intense microwave bursts the relativistic-microwave theory requires [10]?
- Charged windscreens. During thunderstorms, does charge on aircraft windscreens reach the fields Lowke and colleagues' calculations need to sustain a discharge in the cockpit [7]?
- Retinal sensations. For which strike distances and current waveforms do lightning fields exceed the threshold for retinal phosphenes (perceived flashes of light), and do these match where witnesses stood [6]?
- Magnetic monopoles. A 2024 preprint by Stephan, not peer reviewed, argues that the reported frequency of ball lightning does not conflict with limits on the flux of magnetic monopoles; what flux would a monopole origin require [11]? See Magnetic monopoles.
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Abrahamson, J. & Dinniss, J. (2000). Ball lightning caused by oxidation of nanoparticle networks from normal lightning strikes on soil. Nature 403(6769), 519–521. 10.1038/35000525 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Abrahamson, J., Bychkov, A. V. & Bychkov, V. L. (2002). Recently reported sightings of ball lightning: observations collected by correspondence and Russian and Ukrainian sightings. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 360(1790), 11–35 (published online 2001). 10.1098/rsta.2001.0917 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Dikhtyar, V. & Jerby, E. (2006). Fireball ejection from a molten hot spot to air by localized microwaves. Physical Review Letters 96(4), 045002. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.96.045002 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Paiva, G. S., Pavão, A. C., de Vasconcelos, E. A., Mendes, O. & da Silva, E. F. (2007). Production of ball-lightning-like luminous balls by electrical discharges in silicon. Physical Review Letters 98(4), 048501. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.048501 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cooray, G. & Cooray, V. (2008). Could some ball lightning observations be optical hallucinations caused by epileptic seizures? The Open Atmospheric Science Journal 2, 101–105. 10.2174/1874282300802010101 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Peer, J. & Kendl, A. (2010). Transcranial stimulability of phosphenes by long lightning electromagnetic pulses. Physics Letters A 374(29), 2932–2935; erratum and addendum by Peer, J., Cooray, V., Cooray, G. & Kendl, A., 374(47), 4797–4799 (2010), DOI 10.1016/j.physleta.2010.09.071. 10.1016/j.physleta.2010.05.023 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Lowke, J. J., Smith, D., Nelson, K. E., Crompton, R. W. & Murphy, A. B. (2012). Birth of ball lightning. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 117(D19), D19107. 10.1029/2012JD017921 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cen, J., Yuan, P. & Xue, S. (2014). Observation of the optical and spectral characteristics of ball lightning. Physical Review Letters 112(3), 035001. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.035001 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Ball, P. (2014). First spectrum of ball lightning. Physics 7, 5. 10.1103/Physics.7.5 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Wu, H.-C. (2016). Relativistic-microwave theory of ball lightning. Scientific Reports 6, 28263. 10.1038/srep28263 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Stephan, K. D. (2024). Could ball lightning be magnetic monopoles? Preprint, arXiv:2408.10289 (version 1, 19 August 2024), not peer reviewed. Source · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Zhou, C., Zhang, D., Qi, R., Bai, Y., Zeng, Y., Zheng, Z., Song, L., Tian, Y. & Li, R. (2026). Ball-lightning-like relativistic terahertz solitons. Nature Photonics 20(6), 727–733 (published online 16 April 2026). 10.1038/s41566-026-01899-y · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Bulanov, S. (2026). Is ball lightning a relativistic soliton? Nature Photonics 20(6), 611–612 (News & Views, published online 5 June 2026). 10.1038/s41566-026-01914-2 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in physics. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.