Papex

Open problem · Astronomy · since 1950 · Open

Fermi paradox

Why is there no clear evidence of extraterrestrial civilisations?

Summary

Given the vast number of stars and potentially habitable planets, the lack of clear evidence of extraterrestrial civilisations is unexplained.

Why it is open

The Fermi paradox is a conflict between an expectation and an observation [4]. The expectation comes from the number of places where life could arise: in the Drake equation, the number N of detectable civilisations in the Milky Way is a product of seven factors, from the rate of star formation to the fraction of planets that develop life and the average lifetime of a detectable civilisation [4]. Anders Sandberg, Eric Drexler and Toby Ord quote the historian Steven Dick: "Perhaps never in the history of science has an equation been devised yielding values differing by eight orders of magnitude" [4]. The observation is that no clear sign of another civilisation has been found [4].

The name itself is disputed. Enrico Fermi asked "where is everybody?" at a lunch at Los Alamos in 1950; from eyewitness accounts, Robert Gray concludes that he was questioning whether interstellar travel is feasible, not whether extraterrestrials exist [2]. Gray traces the argument "they are not here; therefore they do not exist" to Michael Hart in 1975, and the phrase "Fermi paradox" to a paper of 1977 [2].

It is also several problems. Hart started from what he called "Fact A": "There are no intelligent beings from outer space on Earth now" [1]. Other versions ask why no signals have been received, or why no galaxy-scale engineering is seen [2, 4]. Gray notes that the colonisation argument assumes, among other things, that interstellar travel is feasible and that the Galaxy would fill quickly, and that an argument from missing signals assumes a complete search, which has not been made [2].

No body sets a bar for a resolution. A confirmed detection would end the question. Without one, the routes are to show that silence is expected, as Sandberg and colleagues argue [4], or to search enough of the possible signals that a null result becomes informative [5].

What is known

The colonisation argument (1975–1980). Hart argued that intelligent beings elsewhere in the Galaxy "would eventually have achieved space travel, and would have explored and colonized the Galaxy"; since they are not here, "they do not exist" [1]. He grouped other explanations as physical, sociological or temporal, or as visits that we do not observe, rejected all four, and concluded that "an extensive search for radio messages from other civilizations is probably a waste of time and money" [2]. In 1980 Frank Tipler extended the argument to self-replicating machines, which he estimated could explore or colonise the Galaxy in less than 300 million years [2].

Settlement models (2019). Jonathan Carroll-Nellenback, Adam Frank, Jason Wright and Caleb Scharf modelled advancing settlement fronts and found that the Milky Way "can be readily filled-in with settled stellar systems under conservative assumptions" [6]. Their models also allow steady states in which some settleable systems stay empty, and long-lived clusters of settled systems inside large unsettled regions; these results, they write, "break the link" between Hart's Fact A and the conclusion that humans must be the only technological civilisation in the Galaxy [6].

How much has been searched (2018). Wright, Shubham Kanodia and Emily Lubar modelled the "cosmic haystack" of possible radio signals in eight dimensions and computed the fraction that several large programmes in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) had examined: "similar to the ratio of the volume of a large hot tub or small swimming pool to that of the Earth's oceans" [5].

Radio surveys (2016–2025). Breakthrough Listen, a ten-year search for technosignatures (signs of technology), observed 1,327 nearby stars from January 2016 to March 2019 over 1.10–3.45 GHz and, after excluding terrestrial interference, found zero candidates [7]. A narrowband signal near 982 MHz ("blc1"), recorded towards Proxima Centauri on 29 April 2019, was "not an extraterrestrial technosignature" but an intermodulation product of local interference, Sofia Sheikh and colleagues concluded [9]. A 2025 search of the Green Bank Telescope archive over 1.1–11.2 GHz found that "less than 1% of stars host transmitters brighter than ∼0.3 Arecibo radar equivalents broadcasting in our direction"; an erratum corrected the sample sizes without changing the main findings [14].

Probability arguments (2018–2021). Sandberg, Drexler and Ord replaced point estimates of the Drake factors with distributions spanning current scientific uncertainty [4]. Their model gave a 52% probability that N is below 1 in our galaxy and nearly 38% that we are alone in the observable universe; taking the absence of detections into account raised these to between 53% and 99.6%, and between 39% and 85% [4]. They stress that this "does not mean that we are alone", only that it is "very scientifically plausible"; the paper is a preprint, with no journal reference listed on 14 October 2026 [4]. Andrew Snyder-Beattie, Sandberg, Drexler and Michael Bonsall modelled the timing of evolutionary transitions on Earth, such as abiogenesis, the origin of complex cells and the evolution of sexual reproduction, and concluded that expected transition times "likely exceed the lifetime of Earth", so that intelligent life is "exceptionally rare", assuming that it requires similar transitions elsewhere [8].

Recent claims. In 2024 Matías Suazo and colleagues searched about five million objects in survey data for partial Dyson spheres, megastructures that an advanced civilisation might build to harness its star's energy, and reported seven candidates, all M dwarfs (small, cool stars) whose infrared excess "astrophysical phenomena cannot easily account for" [11]. Tongtian Ren, Michael Garrett and Andrew Siemion found radio sources close to three of them and proposed that dust-obscured background galaxies add to their infrared light, writing that "these three stars have therefore been misidentified" and that such galaxies "can probably account for the contamination" of all seven [12]. In 2025 their high-resolution radio images near candidate G showed a radio-loud active galactic nucleus and no emission at the star, which they say confirms that "at least some" candidates are contaminated [13].

Main approaches

Rare or absent. Technological life is so rare that none exists within reach, as Hart argued, or perhaps anywhere in the observable universe [1, 4]. Strongest evidence: with the uncertainty in the Drake factors carried through, an empty galaxy has a probability of about one half before any search [4], and the timing of transitions on Earth points the same way [8]. Main difficulty: these are statements about knowledge, not measurements [4]. The first result can be driven by the uncertainty in the rate of abiogenesis alone [4], and the second would be reversed by "evidence for much earlier transitions, multiple instances of transitions" or another model, its authors write [8].

Incomplete search. Civilisations may be common, but searches so far cover a tiny part of the space of possible signals [2, 5]. Strongest evidence: the haystack estimate [5]. Main difficulty: the estimate depends on where the haystack's boundaries are drawn, and the authors supply a script for other boundaries [5]. Searches already limit bright transmitters beamed at us from nearby stars [7, 14], and a 2015 infrared survey of about 100,000 galaxies found none hosting a civilisation that reprocesses more than 85% of its starlight into mid-infrared emission [3].

Present but not here. A galaxy can hold space-faring civilisations and still leave Earth unvisited [6]. Strongest evidence: steady-state models with partly settled galaxies and long-lived clusters [6]. Main difficulty: the same models show the Galaxy filling up under conservative assumptions, so this account needs settlement to stop short, for example through finite civilisation lifetimes [6].

Loud and quiet civilisations. Robin Hanson, Daniel Martin, Calvin McCarter and Jonathan Paulson argue that humanity appears early, because "loud" civilisations expand, visibly change the regions they hold and prevent later life there [10]. Strongest evidence: a three-parameter model fitted to the number of "hard steps" in Earth's history, an assumed distribution of our rank among civilisation birth dates, and our not seeing such regions [10]. Main difficulty: the fit rests on those assumptions; and if loud civilisations arise from quiet ones, a transition chance below about 1 in 10,000 is needed to expect even one other quiet civilisation ever active in our galaxy, which the authors call bad news for SETI [10].

Open sub-questions

  1. Haystack accounting. What fraction of Wright et al.'s eight-dimensional haystack does each completed survey add, and what limit on transmitters per star does its null result set in the same units [5, 14]?
  2. Remaining Dyson-sphere candidates. Do high-resolution radio or infrared observations of the other six Hephaistos candidates also find background galaxies, as for candidate G [11, 12, 13]?
  3. Interference at scale. Can a verification procedure like the one used for blc1 run automatically on archival surveys, and how often does interference aligned with the observing cadence mimic a candidate [9]?
  4. An unvisited Earth. In settlement models, which ranges of probe speed, civilisation lifetime and settleable fraction keep Earth unvisited for as long as the geological record could show a visit [6]?
  5. How often life starts. Which observation would most narrow the uncertainty in the rate of abiogenesis that drives Sandberg et al.'s probability of being alone [4]? See the Papex page Origin of life.
  6. Hard steps. Snyder-Beattie et al.'s model predicts that planets orbiting M dwarfs are uninhabitable; which observations of such planets, or new dates for transitions such as the origin of eukaryotes, would test it [8]?

Work on this in Papex

If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.

Key references

  1. Hart, M. H. (1995). An explanation for the absence of extraterrestrials on Earth. In B. Zuckerman & M. H. Hart (eds.), Extraterrestrials: Where Are They? 2nd edn, Cambridge University Press, 1–8. First published in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society 16, 128–135 (1975), as cited in reference 2. 10.1017/CBO9780511564970.003 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  2. Gray, R. H. (2015). The Fermi paradox is neither Fermi's nor a paradox. Astrobiology 15(3), 195–199. 10.1089/ast.2014.1247 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  3. Griffith, R. L., Wright, J. T., Maldonado, J., Povich, M. S., Sigurðsson, S. & Mullan, B. (2015). The Ĝ infrared search for extraterrestrial civilizations with large energy supplies. III. The reddest extended sources in WISE. The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 217(2), 25. 10.1088/0067-0049/217/2/25 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  4. Sandberg, A., Drexler, E. & Ord, T. (2018). Dissolving the Fermi paradox. Preprint, arXiv:1806.02404 (version 1, 6 June 2018), not peer reviewed. Source · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  5. Wright, J. T., Kanodia, S. & Lubar, E. (2018). How much SETI has been done? Finding needles in the n-dimensional cosmic haystack. The Astronomical Journal 156(6), 260. 10.3847/1538-3881/aae099 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  6. Carroll-Nellenback, J., Frank, A., Wright, J. & Scharf, C. (2019). The Fermi paradox and the Aurora effect: exo-civilization settlement, expansion, and steady states. The Astronomical Journal 158(3), 117. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab31a3 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  7. Price, D. C., Enriquez, J. E., Brzycki, B., Croft, S., Czech, D., DeBoer, D. et al. (2020). The Breakthrough Listen search for intelligent life: observations of 1327 nearby stars over 1.10–3.45 GHz. The Astronomical Journal 159(3), 86. 10.3847/1538-3881/ab65f1 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  8. Snyder-Beattie, A. E., Sandberg, A., Drexler, K. E. & Bonsall, M. B. (2021). The timing of evolutionary transitions suggests intelligent life is rare. Astrobiology 21(3), 265–278. 10.1089/ast.2019.2149 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  9. Sheikh, S. Z., Smith, S., Price, D. C., DeBoer, D., Lacki, B. C., Czech, D. J. et al. (2021). Analysis of the Breakthrough Listen signal of interest blc1 with a technosignature verification framework. Nature Astronomy 5(11), 1153–1162. 10.1038/s41550-021-01508-8 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  10. Hanson, R., Martin, D., McCarter, C. & Paulson, J. (2021). If loud aliens explain human earliness, quiet aliens are also rare. The Astrophysical Journal 922(2), 182. 10.3847/1538-4357/ac2369 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  11. Suazo, M., Zackrisson, E., Mahto, P. K., Lundell, F., Nettelblad, C., Korn, A. J., Wright, J. T. & Majumdar, S. (2024). Project Hephaistos – II. Dyson sphere candidates from Gaia DR3, 2MASS, and WISE. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 531(1), 695–707. 10.1093/mnras/stae1186 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  12. Ren, T., Garrett, M. A. & Siemion, A. P. V. (2024). Background contamination of the Project Hephaistos Dyson spheres candidates. Research Notes of the AAS 8(5), 145. 10.3847/2515-5172/ad5017 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  13. Ren, T., Garrett, M. A. & Siemion, A. P. V. (2025). High-resolution imaging of the radio source associated with Project Hephaistos Dyson sphere candidate G. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters 538(1), L56–L61. 10.1093/mnrasl/slaf006 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  14. Painter, C., Croft, S., Lebofsky, M., Andersson, A., Choza, C., Gajjar, V., Price, D. & Siemion, A. P. V. (2025). A novel technosignature search in the Breakthrough Listen Green Bank Telescope archive. The Astronomical Journal 169(4), 222; erratum in 170(3), 194 (2025), DOI 10.3847/1538-3881/adf965. 10.3847/1538-3881/adbc5e · Checked 14 Oct 2026

Page reviewed 14 Oct 2026

Source

Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in astronomy. Checked 29 Sep 2026.

The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.

Records on this problem

No public record addresses this problem yet.

More in Cosmology & astronomy