Transport through the Golgi apparatus
How exactly do proteins travel through the stacked compartments of the Golgi apparatus?
Summary
Why it is open
The Golgi apparatus receives newly made proteins from the endoplasmic reticulum, processes them, notably by assembling sugar chains on them (glycosylation), and sorts them for delivery [13]. It is built from flattened membrane sacs called cisternae [9], usually described as cis, medial and trans cisternae plus the trans-Golgi network (TGN); enzymes that act early in glycosylation are concentrated on the cis side and late-acting ones on the trans side [6]. How the proteins being carried (the cargo) cross this stack is disputed. In the stable compartments model, each cisterna is long-lived and keeps its resident proteins, and vesicles carry cargo from one cisterna to the next. In the cisternal maturation model, each cisterna is transient: cargo stays inside while the cisterna matures from early to late by acquiring and then losing resident proteins [3].
In 2011 Benjamin Glick and Alberto Luini wrote that "it is hardly an exaggeration to state that there are as many different models for Golgi traffic as there are Golgi researchers", and that no single model easily explains all the observations from diverse organisms [6]. Mammalian cisternae are thin and closely stacked, with dimensions of tens of nanometres, below the resolution of conventional light microscopy [10], while the yeast in which maturation has been filmed has unstacked cisternae, which, Hieng Chiong Tie and colleagues write, casts doubt on how generally the yeast observations apply to "higher eukaryotes" [15].
No body sets a bar for a resolution. The sources suggest what is needed: a model that explains distinct compartments, cargo too large for vesicles, and the different speeds and exit kinetics of different cargoes [6, 15], and a direct observation in mammalian cells of the kind made in yeast [13, 15].
What is known
Vesicles and large cargo (1980s–2001). The vesicular transport model was widely accepted from the early 1980s until the late 1990s; electron microscopy and cell-free reconstitution had identified vesicles coated with coat protein complex I (COPI) as carriers between cisternae [6]. In 1998 Lidia Bonfanti and colleagues found that procollagen type I, which forms rigid rods 300 nm long and then large aggregates, crosses the Golgi stack without ever leaving the lumen of the cisternae, concluding that it moves by progressive cisternal maturation [1]. In 2001 José Martínez-Menárguez and colleagues, using immuno-electron microscopy of cultured NRK cells, found Golgi resident proteins such as mannosidase II in the vesicles around the Golgi, while a forward-moving (anterograde) cargo, the viral protein VSV-G, was largely absent [2].
Maturation filmed in yeast (2006–2019). In the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae the cisternae are not stacked and can be resolved individually by fluorescence microscopy [6]. In 2006 Eugene Losev and colleagues saw individual cisternae mature at a consistent rate matching the transport rate of two secretory cargo proteins [3], and Kumi Matsuura-Tokita and colleagues saw cisternae exchange cis for trans resident proteins over time [4]. In 2019 Kazuo Kurokawa and colleagues tracked cargo too: it stays in a cisterna maturing from cis to trans Golgi and on to the TGN, although after reaching the TGN zone a small amount frequently reappears in the earlier zone [12]. Jason Casler and colleagues also found cargo in cisternae throughout maturation, plus a burst of recycling, requiring the adaptor AP-1, that delivers extra cargo to cisternae at the early-to-late transition [11]. All of this direct imaging comes from one yeast species.
Mammalian cells (2008–2017). George Patterson and colleagues, in three mammalian cell types, found that cargo leaves the Golgi at an exponential rate proportional to the amount present, with no lag [5]. Riccardo Rizzo and colleagues made Golgi resident proteins that could be polymerised so that they could not recycle in carriers; in HeLa cells they moved from cis to trans cisternae at the rate reported for cisternal progression, as maturation predicts [8]. Gregory Lavieu and colleagues instead found that membrane "staples" placed in cis cisternae stayed at the cis face for many hours while soluble aggregates moved on, and proposed that only the dilated rims of cisternae progress (rim progression) [7]. In HepG2 human hepatoma cells, Galina Beznoussenko and colleagues found that albumin and α1-antitrypsin crossed the Golgi much faster than procollagen in the same stack, and that albumin appears to diffuse through continuities between cisternae [9]. Myun Hwa Dunlop and colleagues pulled cisternae apart by attaching them to mitochondria in HeLa cells; cargo was still processed and transported, and cis and trans cisternae stayed stable in composition and size [10].
Recent claims (2025). Tie and colleagues, using Golgi "ministacks" made in cultured human cells with the drug nocodazole, found that a cargo slows from cis to trans, that different cargoes move at different speeds within the same cisternae, and that removing the luminal domain of the cargo Tac lengthened its Golgi residence from 16 minutes to 3.4 hours; they read this as supporting stable compartments [15]. eLife's assessment called the evidence "convincing"; the authors note limits (overexpressed cargo, ministacks rather than the native Golgi) and that their data alone cannot resolve a debate of "several decades" and might also fit a refined maturation model [15]. Marinella Pirozzi and colleagues found that cargoes move in order from cis to trans and on to the TGN, accumulate there and then leave with monoexponential kinetics; they propose that exit from the TGN is rate-limiting and attribute the difference from Patterson's results likely to cell type and conditions [13]. Rebecca Taylor and colleagues determined the structure of the COPI coat bound to GOLPH3, an adaptor for many Golgi residents, showing how it engages residents preferentially at late cisternae, which they present as a mechanistic basis for maturation [14].
Main approaches
Stable compartments, with vesicles or mobile rims. Cisternae persist, and cargo moves forward in carriers or in rims that progress [7, 15]. Strongest evidence: separated cisternae keep their identity while transport continues [10], staples in cis cisternae stay put for hours [7], and different cargoes cross at different speeds [15]; some studies found cargo in COPI vesicles, and the model explains distinct compartments and the polarity of enzymes [6]. Main difficulty: procollagen is too large for COPI vesicles [1, 6], several studies found anterograde cargo depleted in COPI vesicles [2, 6], and Glick and Luini cite unpublished calculations that the fast traffic of small cargoes would need hundreds of vesicles per second from each cisterna [6].
Cisternal maturation. New cisternae form at the cis face, mature and carry cargo forward, while COPI vesicles recycle resident proteins to younger cisternae [6]. Strongest evidence: direct imaging of maturation, with cargo inside, in yeast [3, 4, 11, 12]; polymerised residents that progress with cargo in HeLa cells [8]; a structural mechanism for stage-specific recycling by COPI [14]. Glick and Luini proposed it as "the best candidate for a conserved core mechanism of Golgi traffic" [6]. Main difficulty: similar direct observations have not been reported in mammalian cells [15]; a simple version predicts linear exit and equal speeds for all cargoes, contrary to measurements [5, 6, 15]; and some studies found glycosylation enzymes depleted in COPI vesicles [6].
Maturation with fast tracks or cargo recycling. Cisternae mature, but small cargoes also diffuse through tubular connections between cisternae, or part of the cargo recycles backwards [6, 9, 11]. Strongest evidence: albumin crosses faster than procollagen in the same stack [9], and Casler and colleagues suggest that repeated recycling of part of the cargo could explain exponential exit [11]. Main difficulty: such connections have not been convincingly described in fungi and plants, their prevalence in mammalian cells is debated, and it is unclear how gradients across the stack survive them [6].
Rapid partitioning. The Golgi behaves as one mixed system in which cargo partitions between lipid-defined processing and export domains and leaves from every level [5, 6]. Strongest evidence: exponential exit without a lag, and simulations that reproduce Golgi gradients and cargo waves [5]. Main difficulty: the micron-scale lipid domains it invokes have not been observed in cells, and it does not explain procollagen waves or transient yeast cisternae [6]; Pirozzi and colleagues found ordered cis-to-trans movement and accumulation in the TGN, while noting that the segregation of cargo from residents fits their data [13].
Open sub-questions
- Maturation in a mammalian stack. In nocodazole ministacks [15], does the resident-protein composition of one cisterna shift from cis to trans while a synchronised cargo crosses, as in yeast [3, 12]?
- The source of exponential exit. Does removing AP-1 in mammalian cells add a lag to Golgi exit of a synchronised cargo, as cargo recycling would predict [11], or does exit stay monoexponential because the TGN step limits it [5, 13]?
- Truncated Tac. Is the 3.4-hour Golgi residence of Tac without its luminal domain [15] due to retention in a stable cisternal interior or to repeated recycling within maturing cisternae [11]?
- Staples and polymerised residents. Polymerised residents at the cisternal centre moved from cis to trans [8], while staples there stayed at the cis face [7]. Does the difference persist side by side in one cell line under one cargo load?
- Continuities and load. Do the continuities through which albumin diffuses [9] appear only under heavy cargo load, as Glick and Luini consider possible [6]?
- GOLPH3 clients. When GOLPH3 cannot engage COPI [14], do its client enzymes leave the stack at the rate of a synchronised cargo, as maturation predicts for residents that cannot recycle [8]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Bonfanti, L., Mironov, A. A., Martínez-Menárguez, J. A., Martella, O., Fusella, A., Baldassarre, M. et al. (1998). Procollagen traverses the Golgi stack without leaving the lumen of cisternae: evidence for cisternal maturation. Cell 95(7), 993–1003. 10.1016/s0092-8674(00)81723-7 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Martínez-Menárguez, J. A., Prekeris, R., Oorschot, V. M. J., Scheller, R., Slot, J. W., Geuze, H. J. & Klumperman, J. (2001). Peri-Golgi vesicles contain retrograde but not anterograde proteins consistent with the cisternal progression model of intra-Golgi transport. Journal of Cell Biology 155(7), 1213–1224. 10.1083/jcb.200108029 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Losev, E., Reinke, C. A., Jellen, J., Strongin, D. E., Bevis, B. J. & Glick, B. S. (2006). Golgi maturation visualized in living yeast. Nature 441(7096), 1002–1006. 10.1038/nature04717 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Matsuura-Tokita, K., Takeuchi, M., Ichihara, A., Mikuriya, K. & Nakano, A. (2006). Live imaging of yeast Golgi cisternal maturation. Nature 441(7096), 1007–1010. 10.1038/nature04737 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Patterson, G. H., Hirschberg, K., Polishchuk, R. S., Gerlich, D., Phair, R. D. & Lippincott-Schwartz, J. (2008). Transport through the Golgi apparatus by rapid partitioning within a two-phase membrane system. Cell 133(6), 1055–1067. 10.1016/j.cell.2008.04.044 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Glick, B. S. & Luini, A. (2011). Models for Golgi traffic: a critical assessment. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology 3(11), a005215. 10.1101/cshperspect.a005215 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Lavieu, G., Zheng, H. & Rothman, J. E. (2013). Stapled Golgi cisternae remain in place as cargo passes through the stack. eLife 2, e00558. 10.7554/elife.00558 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Rizzo, R., Parashuraman, S., Mirabelli, P., Puri, C., Lucocq, J. & Luini, A. (2013). The dynamics of engineered resident proteins in the mammalian Golgi complex relies on cisternal maturation. Journal of Cell Biology 201(7), 1027–1036. 10.1083/jcb.201211147 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Beznoussenko, G. V., Parashuraman, S., Rizzo, R., Polishchuk, R., Martella, O., Di Giandomenico, D. et al. (2014). Transport of soluble proteins through the Golgi occurs by diffusion via continuities across cisternae. eLife 3, e02009. 10.7554/elife.02009 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Dunlop, M. H., Ernst, A. M., Schroeder, L. K., Toomre, D. K., Lavieu, G. & Rothman, J. E. (2017). Land-locked mammalian Golgi reveals cargo transport between stable cisternae. Nature Communications 8, 432. 10.1038/s41467-017-00570-z · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Casler, J. C., Papanikou, E., Barrero, J. J. & Glick, B. S. (2019). Maturation-driven transport and AP-1–dependent recycling of a secretory cargo in the Golgi. Journal of Cell Biology 218(5), 1582–1601. 10.1083/jcb.201807195 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Kurokawa, K., Osakada, H., Kojidani, T., Waga, M., Suda, Y., Asakawa, H., Haraguchi, T. & Nakano, A. (2019). Visualization of secretory cargo transport within the Golgi apparatus. Journal of Cell Biology 218(5), 1602–1618. 10.1083/jcb.201807194 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Pirozzi, M., Agliarulo, I., Di Martino, R., Marzullo, V. M., Quarto, M., Turacchio, G. et al. (2025). Cargoes move from cis to trans-Golgi compartments and concentrate in the TGN before exiting. EMBO Reports 26(19), 4742–4765. 10.1038/s44319-025-00548-9 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Taylor, R. J., Zubkov, N., Ciazynska, K. A., Kaufman, J. G. G., Tagiltsev, G., Owen, D. J., Briggs, J. A. G. & Munro, S. (2025). The mechanistic basis of cargo selection during Golgi maturation. Science Advances 11(40), eaea0016. 10.1126/sciadv.aea0016 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Tie, H. C., Wang, H., Mahajan, D., Lam, H. Y. I., Sun, X., Chen, B., Mu, Y. & Lu, L. (2025). Quantitative intra-Golgi transport and organization data suggest the stable compartment nature of the Golgi. eLife 13, RP98582 (version of record issued 8 July 2025, with the eLife assessment). 10.7554/elife.98582 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.