Mechanism of allosteric transitions
When a molecule binds to an allosteric protein, do its subunits change shape all together, one by one, or in some other way?
Summary
Why it is open
Allostery is the process by which proteins transmit the effect of binding at one site to another, often distant, site [9]. For decades two models have framed the question [9]. In the concerted model of Jacques Monod, Jeffries Wyman and Jean-Pierre Changeux (MWC, 1965), an allosteric protein is an oligomer of identical units in equivalent positions; it has at least two states, which are in equilibrium even without ligand, and the symmetry of the molecule is conserved when it passes from one state to the other [1]. In the sequential model of Koshland, Némethy and Filmer (KNF, 1966), which took up a 1935 proposal by Pauling for haemoglobin, only the shapes of individual subunits change, each through "induced fit" of its binding site to the ligand, with no switch of the whole quaternary structure [6, 9].
Both are phenomenological models: they describe binding data but do not explain how binding at one site produces the effect at another at the atomic level [6, 9]. In 2014 Hesam Motlagh, James Wrabl, Jing Li and Vincent Hilser wrote that allosteric mechanisms "in most instances remain a biophysical enigma, eluding a general, quantifiable and predictive atomic description" [9].
The problem is therefore several questions: which model, or which extension of one, accounts quantitatively for a given protein's binding and kinetics; whether the effect is carried by changes in average structure or by changes in motion; and whether one description can cover both rigid oligomers and intrinsically disordered proteins, which have no fixed structure but can still be allosteric [6, 9]. No body sets a bar for a resolution. For haemoglobin, Eric Henry, William Eaton and colleagues describe experiments that hold the protein in one quaternary structure (the bonding between its subunits [1]) as "a demanding set of data to test" models of allostery [10].
What is known
Two models (1965–1966). MWC distinguished homotropic effects, between identical ligands, from heterotropic effects, between different ligands, and noted that homotropic effects "appear to be always co-operative": binding of one ligand favours binding of the next [1]. Qiang Cui and Martin Karplus note that negative cooperativity is not treated by the simple MWC model and appears to need a KNF-like description, although an extended MWC model can produce it [6]. They also note that many monomeric proteins are allosteric and that many allosteric proteins are not symmetric, against two MWC assumptions [6].
Haemoglobin (1970–2025). Perutz's crystal structures showed two quaternary structures, deoxy (T, tense) and oxy (R, relaxed), and he proposed that salt bridges link ligand-induced changes within each chain to the relative stability of the two forms [6, 9]. Oxygen binding to haemoglobin trapped in the T structure in single crystals or silica gels is noncooperative, which, Henry and colleagues write, "settled a long-standing controversy by eliminating the sequential model of Koshland, Nemethy, and Filmer from further consideration" [10]. The same experiments "required a major revision of the MWC model": of four models tested, only the tertiary two-state model, which adds equilibria between two shapes of each subunit (its tertiary structure) within each quaternary structure, was consistent with them, "although it is not quantitatively perfect" [10]. Cui and Karplus concluded in 2008 that "we do know how allostery 'works' in vertebrate tetrameric hemoglobins", through fast changes within subunits coupled to a slow quaternary transition [6]. Others describe more complexity. Takashi Yonetani and colleagues found that heterotropic effectors change oxygen affinity, cooperativity and the Bohr effect (the fall in oxygen affinity as pH is lowered) mainly through tertiary changes, so that haemoglobin "can behave energetically beyond what can be explained by the Monod-Wyman-Changeux/Perutz model" [4, 10]. In a 2020 review, Naoya Shibayama concluded from new crystallographic approaches that the transition "involves population shifts in multiple quaternary conformers rather than a simple two-state switch" [12]. In 2025 he reported that the effector bezafibrate and its derivative L35 lowered the oxygen affinity of R-state crystals of horse haemoglobin about threefold and twofold, with binding still noncooperative, and suggested a slight quaternary shift towards T as the cause [15].
Timescales. In time-resolved X-ray scattering, the main structural change of the R-to-T transition occurred about 2 μs after photolysis, the release of bound ligand by a flash of light [7]. As of 2008 the reverse, T-to-R, rate had not been measured, because there is no obvious trigger that synchronises that transition across a sample [6].
Allostery without a change of shape (1984–2014). Cooper and Dryden showed theoretically that ligand-induced changes in the frequencies and amplitudes of thermal fluctuations could produce cooperative free energies of several kJ mol⁻¹ with no change in average conformation, an effect that is mainly entropic [2]. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) later found such cases: in the catabolite activator protein (CAP) and in a PDZ domain, allosteric effects appeared with essentially no structural change [9]. In the signalling protein NtrC, Brian Volkman, Dorothee Kern and colleagues found inactive and active conformations both populated before activation, with phosphorylation shifting the balance [3].
Time-resolved structures (2019–2022). Using time-resolved serial crystallography, Pedram Mehrabi, Emil Pai and colleagues followed the enzyme fluoroacetate dehalogenase through four turnover cycles, from 30 ms to 30 s, and visualised "half-of-the-sites reactivity" (only half of the identical active sites react) with correlated "molecular-breathing" motions [11]. Shuwen Zhang, Youdong Mao and colleagues captured the human proteasome bound to the regulatory enzyme USP14 in 13 conformational states by cryo-electron microscopy and found two parallel pathways of state transitions [14].
Main approaches
Concerted two-state models and extensions. Ligands select among pre-existing states [10]. Strongest evidence: the trapped-haemoglobin experiments, explained by the tertiary two-state extension [10]; in 2012 Changeux found several well-documented proteins "adequately represented by the MWC model" [8]. Main difficulty: Changeux also notes "a few possible exceptions" [8], and haemoglobin itself appears to use more than two quaternary conformers [12].
Sequential models. Each subunit changes shape as it binds [6, 9]. Strongest evidence: negative cooperativity, which the simple MWC model does not treat [6]. Main difficulty: for haemoglobin, noncooperative binding in the T structure excluded the KNF model [10], and extended MWC models can also produce negative cooperativity [6].
Dynamic allostery. Binding changes motion, and therefore entropy, rather than average structure [2]. Strongest evidence: the CAP and PDZ studies [9]. Main difficulty: whether CAP's entropic penalty comes wholly from quenched dynamics is, Motlagh and colleagues write, "an open question" [9]; a time-resolved infrared study of a PDZ domain found very subtle shifts among a few well-defined states, and its authors propose that structural and dynamic allostery "go hand-in-hand" [13].
Ensemble models. K. Gunasekaran, Buyong Ma and Ruth Nussinov argued in 2004 that all non-fibrous proteins are potentially allosteric, because allostery follows from redistributing conformational ensembles [5]. Motlagh, Hilser and colleagues model activity as an ensemble-weighted contribution of all states, so that a perturbation that changes which sub-ensemble dominates can turn activation into repression [9]. Strongest evidence: allostery in locally unfolded and disordered proteins, and NtrC's pre-existing populations [3, 9]. Main difficulty: Cui and Karplus reply that a "population shift" is the basis of the MWC model and a thermodynamic description that "does not provide mechanistic details" [6].
Open sub-questions
- Missing haemoglobin structures. Can the structures of a liganded subunit within the T quaternary structure and an unliganded subunit within R, which Henry et al. say the tertiary two-state model needs, be determined [10]?
- α and β separately. Do gel-encapsulated metal hybrids, in which only α or only β subunits bind ligand, confirm the unequal tertiary constants that gave the best fit [10]?
- Triggering T to R. Can a time-resolved experiment synchronise the T-to-R transition as photolysis does for R to T [6, 7]?
- Effectors within one quaternary state. Do effectors lower the affinity of R-state crystals through a slight quaternary shift towards T, as Shibayama suggests, or through tertiary changes as in Yonetani's account [4, 15]?
- Entropy in CAP. What fraction of CAP's entropic penalty comes from quenched protein dynamics [9]?
- Multi-state machines. Do the proteasome's two USP14 pathways behave as distinct sub-ensembles in the sense of the ensemble model [9, 14]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Monod, J., Wyman, J. & Changeux, J.-P. (1965). On the nature of allosteric transitions: a plausible model. Journal of Molecular Biology 12(1), 88–118. 10.1016/S0022-2836(65)80285-6 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cooper, A. & Dryden, D. T. F. (1984). Allostery without conformational change. A plausible model. European Biophysics Journal 11(2), 103–109. 10.1007/BF00276625 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Volkman, B. F., Lipson, D., Wemmer, D. E. & Kern, D. (2001). Two-state allosteric behavior in a single-domain signaling protein. Science 291(5512), 2429–2433. 10.1126/science.291.5512.2429 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Yonetani, T., Park, S. I., Tsuneshige, A., Imai, K. & Kanaori, K. (2002). Global allostery model of hemoglobin: modulation of O2 affinity, cooperativity, and Bohr effect by heterotropic allosteric effectors. Journal of Biological Chemistry 277(37), 34508–34520. 10.1074/jbc.M203135200 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Gunasekaran, K., Ma, B. & Nussinov, R. (2004). Is allostery an intrinsic property of all dynamic proteins? Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics 57(3), 433–443. 10.1002/prot.20232 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cui, Q. & Karplus, M. (2008). Allostery and cooperativity revisited. Protein Science 17(8), 1295–1307. 10.1110/ps.03259908 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cammarata, M., Levantino, M., Wulff, M. & Cupane, A. (2010). Unveiling the timescale of the R–T transition in human hemoglobin. Journal of Molecular Biology 400(5), 951–962. 10.1016/j.jmb.2010.05.057 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Changeux, J.-P. (2012). Allostery and the Monod-Wyman-Changeux model after 50 years. Annual Review of Biophysics 41, 103–133. 10.1146/annurev-biophys-050511-102222 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Motlagh, H. N., Wrabl, J. O., Li, J. & Hilser, V. J. (2014). The ensemble nature of allostery. Nature 508(7496), 331–339. 10.1038/nature13001 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Henry, E. R., Mozzarelli, A., Viappiani, C., Abbruzzetti, S., Bettati, S., Ronda, L., Bruno, S. & Eaton, W. A. (2015). Experiments on hemoglobin in single crystals and silica gels distinguish among allosteric models. Biophysical Journal 109(6), 1264–1272. 10.1016/j.bpj.2015.04.037 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Mehrabi, P., Schulz, E. C., Dsouza, R., Müller-Werkmeister, H. M., Tellkamp, F., Miller, R. J. D. & Pai, E. F. (2019). Time-resolved crystallography reveals allosteric communication aligned with molecular breathing. Science 365(6458), 1167–1170. 10.1126/science.aaw9904 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Shibayama, N. (2020). Allosteric transitions in hemoglobin revisited. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) – General Subjects 1864(2), 129335. 10.1016/j.bbagen.2019.03.021 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Bozovic, O., Zanobini, C., Gulzar, A., Jankovic, B., Buhrke, D., Post, M., Wolf, S., Stock, G. & Hamm, P. (2020). Real-time observation of ligand-induced allosteric transitions in a PDZ domain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117(42), 26031–26039. 10.1073/pnas.2012999117 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Zhang, S., Zou, S., Yin, D., Zhao, L., Finley, D., Wu, Z. & Mao, Y. (2022). USP14-regulated allostery of the human proteasome by time-resolved cryo-EM. Nature 605(7910), 567–574. 10.1038/s41586-022-04671-8 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Shibayama, N. (2025). Effects of allosteric effectors on oxygen binding to crystals of hemoglobin in the R-quaternary structure. Protein Science 34(1), e5232 (published online 2024). 10.1002/pro.5232 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.