Papex

Open problem · Astronomy · Open

Origin of the p-nuclei

Which astrophysical processes produce the rare proton-rich isotopes known as p-nuclei?

Summary

About 35 naturally occurring proton-rich isotopes between selenium and mercury cannot be made by the slow or rapid neutron-capture processes that build most heavy elements; where and how they form is not completely understood.

Why it is open

Most nuclei heavier than iron are made by two neutron-capture processes, the slow s-process and the rapid r-process; a small number of naturally occurring proton-rich isotopes, the p-nuclei, cannot be made in either [3]. Historically 35 were counted, from selenium-74 to mercury-196, but the list depends on s-process models: if s- and r-process contributions account for indium-113, tin-115, gadolinium-152, erbium-164 and tantalum-180, 30 remain to be explained [3]. Their abundances are one to two orders of magnitude below those of neighbouring s- and r-isotopes, except for molybdenum-92 and -94 and ruthenium-96 and -98 [3].

No element is dominated by its p-isotopes, so p-abundances are known only from solar-system material, mainly meteorites, and cannot be measured in other stars; their build-up over the Galaxy's history cannot be traced directly [3]. The models also rely on reaction rates for many unstable nuclei that are only predicted by theory [3]. In 2013 T. Rauscher and colleagues wrote that "so far it seems to be impossible to reproduce the solar abundances of the remaining 30 p-isotopes by one single process" [3]. The name adds confusion: "p-process" first meant proton capture, and is now often used for whatever makes the p-nuclei [3].

No body sets a bar for a resolution. Rauscher and colleagues expect progress from nuclear experiments and theory combined with "improved, self-consistent hydrodynamic simulations of the possible production sites", and note that meteorites provide "strong constraints for any new process" [3].

What is known

The name (1957). In 1957 E. M. Burbidge, G. R. Burbidge, W. A. Fowler and F. Hoyle, and A. G. W. Cameron, saw that some proton-rich isotopes can never be made by neutron captures and beta decays, and postulated a third process, at first thought to be proton capture; Burbidge and colleagues placed it in the hydrogen-rich envelopes of supernovae, which were later found not to be hot enough [3].

The γ-process in massive stars. The long-favoured source is the γ-process (gamma process): when a massive star explodes, temperatures of 2 to 3.5 billion kelvin in its oxygen and neon layers partly break up s- and r-process nuclei already present by photodisintegration, in which energetic photons knock out neutrons, protons or α particles, leaving proton-rich isotopes [3]. Its yields scale with the star's initial stock of heavy seed nuclei [3]. In models of solar initial composition, p-nuclei with mass numbers 124 to 150 and 168 to 200 are made in solar abundance ratios within about a factor of 2 relative to oxygen-16, but those below 124 and from 150 to 165 are severely underproduced [3]. Molybdenum-92 and -94 and ruthenium-96 and -98 cannot be made this way, for lack of seed nuclei in their mass region [3]. Lanthanum-138, which the γ-process cannot make, and probably much of tantalum-180m can instead come from neutrino reactions on stable nuclei, the ν-process [3]. How these explosions happen is itself open; see the Papex page Core-collapse supernova mechanism.

The νp-process (2006). In 2006 C. Fröhlich and colleagues described how, in proton-rich matter ejected under strong neutrino fluxes in a supernova, antineutrino absorption on protons makes neutrons that are captured at once by neutron-deficient nuclei, carrying nucleosynthesis beyond mass number 64; they proposed it as "a possible candidate" for the molybdenum and ruthenium p-isotopes [1]. Its yields "depend sensitively" on the explosion mechanism, the neutrino emission of the newly formed neutron star and the motion of the ejecta [3], and on (n,p) reactions starting at nickel-56 that set how quickly matter moves to heavier nuclei [3].

Type Ia supernovae (2011–2016). A thermonuclear explosion of a white dwarf rich in s-process material runs a γ-process on different seeds [3]. In 2011 C. Travaglio and colleagues used two-dimensional models of white dwarfs that reach the Chandrasekhar mass by accreting from a companion, with enhanced s-process seeds, and found light and heavy p-nuclei made at nearly flat production factors, "including the very debated neutron magic" molybdenum and ruthenium isotopes [2]. In 2015, with a model of the Galaxy's chemical evolution, they estimated that if normal type Ia supernovae come from such single-degenerate systems (a white dwarf with a companion star), they make "at least 50%" of solar-system p-nuclei [3, 4]. In 2016 Maria Lugaro and colleagues found that a type Ia origin of niobium-92, an extinct radioactive p-nuclide recorded in meteorites, cannot be reconciled with manganese-53 within current uncertainties unless the early niobium-92 to molybdenum-92 ratio is at least 50% below its nominal value; the alternative they identify is core-collapse supernovae [3, 5].

Meteorites. Rauscher and colleagues argue from niobium-92 that processes making molybdenum-92 without niobium-92 cannot have contributed much to the cloud that formed the Solar System, which would rule out a significant contribution from very proton-rich environments at and above molybdenum [3]. In 2023 Kurt Marti, Mario Fischer-Gödde and Carina Proksche reported that molybdenum and ruthenium isotope variations in meteorites require distinct p-process components for molybdenum-92 and molybdenum-94 [11].

Nuclear data. For α-particle captures at γ-process energies, standard predictions are up to 2 to 3 times too high in some cases; for samarium-144(α,γ)gadolinium-148, which sets the samarium-144 to samarium-146 production ratio, the measured cross-section is more than an order of magnitude below the standard prediction [3]. Marco Pignatari and colleagues write that "a large effort from nuclear physics is needed" to obtain the relevant rates far from stability [6].

Recent results (2018–2022). In 2018 Julia Bliss, A. Arcones and Y.-Z. Qian found that proton-rich neutrino-driven winds can make dominant contributions to solar ruthenium-98 and significant contributions to ruthenium-96 and molybdenum-92 and -94, and that early supernova ejecta can dominate molybdenum-92 [7]. In 2020 Zewei Xiong and colleagues found that fast flavour oscillations, rapid changes of neutrino type close to the newly formed neutron star, could make winds more proton-rich and greatly enhance selenium-74, krypton-78 and strontium-84 [9]. In the same year Shilun Jin and colleagues reported in Nature that scattering by protons and neutrons in dense outflows raises the rate of the triple-α reaction, which turns helium into carbon, by up to an order of magnitude; this suppresses the νp-process and "casts doubt" on it as the explanation of the molybdenum and ruthenium p-isotopes [8]. In 2022 A. Choplin and colleagues found in rotating 25-solar-mass models that, from no to fast rotation, p-process yields below mass number 140 rise by 3 to 4 orders of magnitude, and suggested that the contribution of core-collapse supernovae has been underestimated [10].

Main approaches

γ-process in core-collapse supernovae. Strongest evidence: it occurs naturally in models and, with the ν-process, "explains the bulk of the p-abundances" [3]; rotation can raise the seeds and the yields [10]. Main difficulty: the deficit at mass numbers 150 to 165 may yield to better reaction rates, but the severe underproduction of light p-nuclei "may point to a principle difficulty" [3]; the rotating models cover one stellar mass and still await a study across masses, metallicities and Galactic history [10].

γ-process in type Ia supernovae. Strongest evidence: two-dimensional models co-produce light and heavy p-nuclei at nearly flat factors, and chemical evolution gives at least half of the solar p-nuclei [2, 4]. Main difficulty: the result needs strongly enhanced s-process seeds, self-consistent models are missing, and the share of single-degenerate events is debated [3]; molybdenum-94 departs from the pattern [4], and niobium-92 does not fit with manganese-53 [5].

νp-process in neutrino-driven ejecta. Strongest evidence: it reaches beyond mass number 64 [1], proton-rich winds can supply much of ruthenium-98 [7], and fast flavour oscillations may raise the yields of light p-nuclei [9]. Main difficulty: the enhanced triple-α rate suppresses it [8], its yields depend on uncertain explosion and neutrino physics [3], and the niobium-92 argument limits very proton-rich contributions at and above molybdenum [3].

Several contributing sites. Rauscher and colleagues see "several (independently operating) processes" contributing [3]. Strongest evidence: distinct p-process components for molybdenum-92 and -94 in meteorites [11]. Main difficulty: the share of each site cannot be read from stellar spectra, in which p-isotopes cannot be separated, so it rests on models of each site and of Galactic chemical evolution [3].

Open sub-questions

  1. Triple-α in winds. With the in-medium triple-α rate included [8], how much of solar ruthenium-98 and molybdenum-92 can proton-rich winds still supply [7]?
  2. Flavour oscillations. Do supernova models that follow fast flavour oscillations self-consistently reproduce the selenium-74, krypton-78 and strontium-84 enhancement estimated by Xiong et al. [9]?
  3. α-capture rates. Which model of the α-nucleus interaction fits the samarium-144(α,γ) data, and does it reduce the γ-process deficit at mass numbers 150 to 165 [3]?
  4. Niobium-92. Which site yields the meteoritic niobium-92 to molybdenum-92 ratio while matching manganese-53 [5]?
  5. Rotation. Do rotating massive-star models across masses and metallicities, folded into Galactic chemical evolution, reproduce the solar p-pattern [10]?
  6. Two molybdenum components. Which pair of sites accounts for the distinct molybdenum-92 and -94 components found in meteorites [11]?

Work on this in Papex

If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.

Key references

  1. Fröhlich, C., Martínez-Pinedo, G., Liebendörfer, M., Thielemann, F.-K., Bravo, E., Hix, W. R., Langanke, K. & Zinner, N. T. (2006). Neutrino-induced nucleosynthesis of A > 64 nuclei: the νp process. Physical Review Letters 96(14), 142502. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.96.142502 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  2. Travaglio, C., Röpke, F. K., Gallino, R. & Hillebrandt, W. (2011). Type Ia supernovae as sites of the p-process: two-dimensional models coupled to nucleosynthesis. The Astrophysical Journal 739(2), 93. 10.1088/0004-637X/739/2/93 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  3. Rauscher, T., Dauphas, N., Dillmann, I., Fröhlich, C., Fülöp, Zs. & Gyürky, Gy. (2013). Constraining the astrophysical origin of the p-nuclei through nuclear physics and meteoritic data. Reports on Progress in Physics 76(6), 066201. 10.1088/0034-4885/76/6/066201 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  4. Travaglio, C., Gallino, R., Rauscher, T., Röpke, F. K. & Hillebrandt, W. (2015). Testing the role of SNe Ia for Galactic chemical evolution of p-nuclei with two-dimensional models and with s-process seeds at different metallicities. The Astrophysical Journal 799(1), 54. 10.1088/0004-637X/799/1/54 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  5. Lugaro, M., Pignatari, M., Ott, U., Zuber, K., Travaglio, C., Gyürky, G. & Fülöp, Z. (2016). Origin of the p-process radionuclides 92Nb and 146Sm in the early solar system and inferences on the birth of the Sun. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113(4), 907–912. 10.1073/pnas.1519344113 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  6. Pignatari, M., Göbel, K., Reifarth, R. & Travaglio, C. (2016). The production of proton-rich isotopes beyond iron: the γ-process in stars. International Journal of Modern Physics E 25(4), 1630003. 10.1142/S0218301316300034 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  7. Bliss, J., Arcones, A. & Qian, Y.-Z. (2018). Production of Mo and Ru isotopes in neutrino-driven winds: implications for solar abundances and presolar grains. The Astrophysical Journal 866(2), 105. 10.3847/1538-4357/aade8d · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  8. Jin, S., Roberts, L. F., Austin, S. M. & Schatz, H. (2020). Enhanced triple-α reaction reduces proton-rich nucleosynthesis in supernovae. Nature 588(7836), 57–60. 10.1038/s41586-020-2948-7 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  9. Xiong, Z., Sieverding, A., Sen, M. & Qian, Y.-Z. (2020). Potential impact of fast flavor oscillations on neutrino-driven winds and their nucleosynthesis. The Astrophysical Journal 900(2), 144. 10.3847/1538-4357/abac5e · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  10. Choplin, A., Goriely, S., Hirschi, R., Tominaga, N. & Meynet, G. (2022). The p-process in exploding rotating massive stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 661, A86. 10.1051/0004-6361/202243331 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  11. Marti, K., Fischer-Gödde, M. & Proksche, C. (2023). Meteoritic molybdenum and ruthenium isotopic abundances document nucleosynthetic p-process components. The Astrophysical Journal 956(1), 7. 10.3847/1538-4357/acee81 · Checked 16 Oct 2026

Page reviewed 16 Oct 2026

Source

Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in astronomy. Checked 08 Oct 2026.

The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.

Records on this problem

No public record addresses this problem yet.

More in Cosmology & astronomy