Cell size control
How do cells determine how large to grow before they divide?
Summary
Why it is open
In a 2021 primer Nicholas Rhind calls "How do cells know how big they are?" a fundamental and still mysterious question: populations of cells keep their size within narrow limits, yet a biochemical understanding of how the proposed mechanisms might work "is only beginning to be developed" [12]. Volume, length, surface area and protein content can vary independently, and it is unclear which of them, if any, cells actually measure [12].
The question has two levels. The first is the rule that links growth to division. In a sizer, a cell passes a cell-cycle transition on reaching a threshold size; in a timer, it grows for a fixed time; in an adder, it adds a fixed amount between two events whatever its size at birth [3, 12]. The rules are told apart by the correlation between size at birth and growth in the following cycle: negative for a sizer, none for an adder, and positive for a timer in cells that grow exponentially [12]. The second level is the molecular mechanism, which the rule does not reveal: in 2019 Fangwei Si and colleagues wrote that the mechanism of the bacterial adder had been unknown "despite intense efforts" [6].
No body sets a bar for a resolution. Rhind's open questions point to what one would need: whether mechanisms are conserved, since size control "does not seem to be conserved between bacteria and eukaryotes, or even between budding yeast and fission yeast", and how a sensing protein could be made at a concentration that depends on cell size, "perhaps the biggest current mystery in the field of cell-size control" [12].
What is known
Rules in bacteria (2014–2015). Manuel Campos and colleagues reported "direct experimental evidence disproving the critical size paradigm": Escherichia coli and Caulobacter crescentus grow, on average, the same amount between divisions irrespective of their length at birth [2]. Sattar Taheri-Araghi and colleagues followed hundreds of thousands of E. coli and Bacillus subtilis cells in a microfluidic "mother machine" across a wide range of steady-state growth conditions, and found that cells add a constant volume each generation irrespective of their size at birth [3]. Rhind describes the adder as apparently the dominant strategy in bacteria, "and perhaps also in archaea" [12].
Bacterial mechanisms (2019). Si and colleagues proposed that the adder follows from two general processes: proteins needed for division accumulate to a fixed number, and they are made in proportion to volume growth [6]. Oscillating the concentration of the division protein FtsZ made division size oscillate and broke the adder, whereas oscillating DnaA, the protein that starts DNA replication, changed size at replication initiation but not at division; they concluded that division processes alone drive size homeostasis [6]. Slow growth is "the only known steady-state growth condition" in which E. coli departs markedly from the adder [6]. Guillaume Witz and colleagues, imaging E. coli at slow and fast growth, concluded instead that the volume added since the last replication initiation sets the timing of both the next division and the next initiation, a "double adder" [7].
Budding yeast (2015–2022). In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, size control acts in G1 before Start, the point of commitment to division [4]. Kurt Schmoller and colleagues reported that the activator Cln3 stays at a nearly constant concentration before Start, while the inhibitor Whi5 is made in S/G2/M phases in a largely size-independent amount and then diluted by growth, so smaller daughter cells are born with more concentrated Whi5 and spend longer in G1 [4]. Athanasios Litsios and colleagues instead measured pulses of protein production peaking around Start and a resulting rise in Cln3 concentration, which they proposed drives Start [8]. Felix Barber, Ariel Amir and Andrew Murray made Whi5 concentration independent of size with the inducible GAL1 promoter; at a level giving the normal mean size, size distributions matched wild type, and they concluded that size control "does not fundamentally originate from the linear accumulation of Whi5" [10]. In a 2022 letter with data from five laboratories, Schmoller and colleagues confirmed Whi5 dilution, found that Whi5 concentration fell from birth to Start in 44 of 49 single-cell traces from Litsios and colleagues' own data, saw no dramatic rise in protein synthesis before Start, and called Whi5 dilution "one of likely several mechanisms" [13]. All of this evidence comes from one species.
Animal cells (2018–2025). Clotilde Cadart and colleagues measured single-cell volume through whole cycles in several mammalian cell lines and primary human cells; most cell types behaved close to an adder, adjusting G1 or S–G2 duration as well as growth rate [5]. Xili Liu, Jiawei Yan and Marc Kirschner found in cultured human cell lines that mass homeostasis is maintained throughout the cycle, even when the normal G1/S machinery is disrupted [14]. Evgeny Zatulovskiy and colleagues reported that growth in G1 dilutes the inhibitor Rb (the retinoblastoma protein): extra Rb increased size and G1 length, and deleting RB reduced size and removed the inverse correlation between birth size and G1 length, in cultured cells, chiefly immortalised human mammary epithelial cells [11]. In living mice, Shicong Xie and colleagues found that epidermal stem cells time S-phase entry by their current size, more tightly than reported in culture; deleting Rb1 alone had minimal effect, but deleting it with its relative Rbl1 removed the dependence of G1 length on birth size [15]. How whole organs reach their size is a separate problem, organ size control.
Scaling of organelles. Structures inside the cell also scale with it. When Matthew Good and colleagues enclosed Xenopus egg and embryo cytoplasm in droplets of defined size, the mitotic spindle shrank with droplet size, depending on volume rather than shape [1]. Cell size also scales with genome content in ploidy series across eukaryotes, which led to the view that cells maintain a target nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio [12].
Main approaches
Threshold accumulation. A structure needed for division forms once a fixed number of its subunits has been made, and subunits are made in proportion to growth [6, 12]. Strongest evidence: the FtsZ experiments changed division size as predicted [6]. Main difficulty: the double-adder analysis ties division to replication initiation rather than to division proteins alone [7], and the evidence comes from a few model bacteria [2, 3, 6].
Inhibitor dilution. An inhibitor of cell-cycle entry is made in a size-independent amount and diluted by growth [4, 11]. Strongest evidence: Whi5 dilution reproduced in five laboratories in budding yeast [13], and the loss of G1 size dependence in mouse epidermis lacking both Rb1 and Rbl1 [15]. Main difficulty: yeast keep normal size distributions when Whi5 concentration no longer depends on size [10], human cell lines keep mass homeostasis when G1/S control is disrupted [14], and in 2021 Rhind noted that how either inhibitor is made in a size-independent amount was unknown [12]; for Whi5, Schmoller and colleagues point to size-independent transcription and partitioning on chromatin [13].
Activator accumulation. An activator rises in concentration as the cell grows [8, 12]. Strongest evidence: the measured rise in Cln3 concentration before Start [8]. Main difficulty: the re-analysis of the same study's Whi5 traces and the absence of a protein-synthesis surge in other laboratories [13]; and Rhind wrote in 2021 that a mechanism for making a protein at a size-dependent concentration had been proposed only in plants [12].
Geometric sensing. Cells read a geometric quantity at the membrane [9]. Strongest evidence: fission yeast (Schizosaccharomyces pombe), described in 2019 as the best-characterised sizer, divide at a fixed surface area through the kinase Cdr2, whose density of membrane clusters scales with cell size; a Cdr2 mutant predicted by a model made thin cells divide at constant length instead [9]. Main difficulty: without Cdr2 a second sizer, based more closely on volume, remains, and the evidence is from this one species [9].
Growth-rate modulation. Cells adjust how fast they grow to their size, alongside changes in cycle length [5, 14]. Strongest evidence: single-cell volume and mass measurements in several cell lines [5, 14]. Main difficulty: the authors call for further studies to find the molecular mechanisms [14], and stem cells in living tissue show strong G1 size control [15].
Limiting components for organelles. Assembly depletes a finite pool of subunits, so size follows cell volume [1]. Strongest evidence: a model of soluble tubulin depletion matched spindle size in droplets and embryos [1]. Main difficulty: adding tubulin did not change spindle scaling, which the authors attribute to other spindle factors also being limiting [1].
Open sub-questions
- Slow-growing bacteria. In slow-growing E. coli, which departs from the adder, does accumulated FtsZ [6] or volume added since replication initiation [7] better predict division size?
- Backup to Whi5. In yeast whose Whi5 concentration no longer depends on size [10], which G1 regulator still changes concentration with size, and does removing that change too widen the size distribution [10, 13]?
- Rb and its relative. Why does deleting RB alone remove G1 size dependence in cultured human cells [11], while in mouse epidermis Rbl1 must also be deleted [15]?
- Culture versus tissue. Do cultured lines that behave as adders [5] show the tighter G1 control seen in epidermis [15] when grown under tissue-like conditions?
- The volume sizer in fission yeast. Which molecule sets division by volume in cells lacking Cdr2 [9]?
- Other limiting spindle factors. Which factors besides tubulin limit spindle size in small droplets [1]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Good, M. C., Vahey, M. D., Skandarajah, A., Fletcher, D. A. & Heald, R. (2013). Cytoplasmic volume modulates spindle size during embryogenesis. Science 342(6160), 856–860. 10.1126/science.1243147 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Campos, M., Surovtsev, I. V., Kato, S., Paintdakhi, A., Beltran, B., Ebmeier, S. E. & Jacobs-Wagner, C. (2014). A constant size extension drives bacterial cell size homeostasis. Cell 159(6), 1433–1446. 10.1016/j.cell.2014.11.022 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Taheri-Araghi, S., Bradde, S., Sauls, J. T., Hill, N. S., Levin, P. A., Paulsson, J. et al. (2015). Cell-size control and homeostasis in bacteria. Current Biology 25(3), 385–391; erratum 27(9), 1392 (2017; an error in Equation 1 and a Figure 4B annotation, which the authors state does not affect the results). 10.1016/j.cub.2014.12.009 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Schmoller, K. M., Turner, J. J., Kõivomägi, M. & Skotheim, J. M. (2015). Dilution of the cell cycle inhibitor Whi5 controls budding-yeast cell size. Nature 526(7572), 268–272. 10.1038/nature14908 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Cadart, C., Monnier, S., Grilli, J., Sáez, P. J., Srivastava, N., Attia, R. et al. (2018). Size control in mammalian cells involves modulation of both growth rate and cell cycle duration. Nature Communications 9, 3275. 10.1038/s41467-018-05393-0 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Si, F., Le Treut, G., Sauls, J. T., Vadia, S., Levin, P. A. & Jun, S. (2019). Mechanistic origin of cell-size control and homeostasis in bacteria. Current Biology 29(11), 1760–1770.e7. 10.1016/j.cub.2019.04.062 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Witz, G., van Nimwegen, E. & Julou, T. (2019). Initiation of chromosome replication controls both division and replication cycles in E. coli through a double-adder mechanism. eLife 8, e48063. 10.7554/eLife.48063 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Litsios, A., Huberts, D. H. E. W., Terpstra, H. M., Guerra, P., Schmidt, A., Buczak, K. et al. (2019). Differential scaling between G1 protein production and cell size dynamics promotes commitment to the cell division cycle in budding yeast. Nature Cell Biology 21(11), 1382–1392. 10.1038/s41556-019-0413-3 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Facchetti, G., Knapp, B., Flor-Parra, I., Chang, F. & Howard, M. (2019). Reprogramming Cdr2-dependent geometry-based cell size control in fission yeast. Current Biology 29(2), 350–358.e4. 10.1016/j.cub.2018.12.017 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Barber, F., Amir, A. & Murray, A. W. (2020). Cell-size regulation in budding yeast does not depend on linear accumulation of Whi5. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117(25), 14243–14250. 10.1073/pnas.2001255117 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Zatulovskiy, E., Zhang, S., Berenson, D. F., Topacio, B. R. & Skotheim, J. M. (2020). Cell growth dilutes the cell cycle inhibitor Rb to trigger cell division. Science 369(6502), 466–471. 10.1126/science.aaz6213 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Rhind, N. (2021). Cell-size control. Current Biology 31(21), R1414–R1420. 10.1016/j.cub.2021.09.017 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Schmoller, K. M., Lanz, M. C., Kim, J., Koivomagi, M., Qu, Y., Tang, C. et al. (2022). Whi5 is diluted and protein synthesis does not dramatically increase in pre-Start G1. Molecular Biology of the Cell 33(5), lt1 (a letter). 10.1091/mbc.E21-01-0029 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Liu, X., Yan, J. & Kirschner, M. W. (2024). Cell size homeostasis is tightly controlled throughout the cell cycle. PLOS Biology 22(1), e3002453. 10.1371/journal.pbio.3002453 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Xie, S., Zhang, S., de Medeiros, G., Liberali, P. & Skotheim, J. M. (2025). The G1/S transition in mammalian stem cells in vivo is autonomously regulated by cell size. Nature Communications 16, 9071. 10.1038/s41467-025-64150-2 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.