Control of organ size and shape
How do organs reliably grow to the correct shape and size?
Summary
Why it is open
Organs reach their characteristic size even when experiments change how many cells they contain or how large the cells are: in the fruit fly wing, altering the cell cycle changed cell numbers over a four- to fivefold range without changing final wing size [13]. How organs stop growing, and how related species produce organs of strikingly different size, have "no definitive answer", Jannik Vollmer, Fernando Casares and Dagmar Iber wrote in 2017 [13]. In 2019 Timothy Saunders and Philip Ingham listed "How are final organ shape and size so reliably formed?" among the open questions of organ formation, and called the cellular interpretation of mechanical information "a major outstanding question" [14].
The problem has several parts. One is where control lies: inside the organ (intrinsic control) or in the rest of the body, for example through nutrition (extrinsic control); the balance differs between organs, even within one species [13]. Another is how a growing organ senses its own size and stops. A third is shape, which depends on how growth is distributed across a tissue and on the mechanical stress that uneven growth produces [12]. How individual cells set their size is a separate problem, cell size control; at the organ level, a change in cell size can be compensated by a change in cell number [13].
No body sets a bar for a resolution. Vollmer and colleagues ask for a mechanism that also explains why growth rates decline with developmental time across the animal kingdom [13]. Kenneth Irvine and Boris Shraiman wrote in 2017 that "the ultimate question of how tissue and body shape is actually encoded in the 'executable program' of development is still open" [12]. Most of the experimental evidence below comes from model organisms: fruit fly imaginal discs (the larval precursors of adult limbs and organs) [2], mice and salamanders.
What is known
Inside or outside the organ (1931–2015). Early transplant experiments in salamanders gave ambiguous results [13]. Victor Twitty and Joseph Schwind (1931) fed the animals maximally to separate organ-intrinsic factors from nutrition, then grafted eyes and limbs between embryos of a larger and a smaller species, Ambystoma tigrinum and A. punctatum; the grafts grew at about the same rate and to about the same size as the corresponding organs left on the donor [13]. In mice, D. Metcalf found in the 1960s that several fetal thymus glands grafted into one animal each grew to normal size, while several fetal spleens together reached the mass of one adult spleen [13]. Organs also differ in regrowth. In mammals, liver mass returns to within 5% of its original value a few days after lobes are removed surgically; in animals with joined circulations (parabiosis), partial removal of one liver makes both grow, which points to systemic factors that were "still unidentified" in 2015 [8]. The thymus, kidney, gut and cartilage growth plates do not alter their growth after transplantation [8]. In 2007 Ben Stanger, Akemi Tanaka and Douglas Melton reduced the progenitor cells of mouse embryos and found that final pancreas size was limited by the progenitor pool, whereas liver size was not [3].
The Hippo pathway (2005–2019). In Drosophila the kinases Hippo and Warts form a growth-suppressing cascade [1, 4]. In 2005 Jianbin Huang and colleagues identified its target, Yorkie, the fly counterpart of the mammalian transcriptional co-activator YAP; overexpressing Yorkie caused increased proliferation, defective cell death and tissue overgrowth [1]. In mammals the cascade ends by phosphorylating YAP and TAZ, the mammalian counterparts of Yorkie [15]. In 2007 Jixin Dong and colleagues switched on YAP in the livers of young mice: liver mass reached 25% of body weight after four weeks, through more cells rather than larger ones, and returned to near normal size two weeks after YAP was switched off [4]. The effect depends on the organ. Yonggang Zheng and Duojia Pan listed the lung, kidney, limb, intestine, mammary gland and pancreas as organs in which loss of Hippo signalling does not increase overall size, and suggested that progenitor number may explain why the pancreas differs from the liver [15]. How the cascade responds to signals such as cell adhesion, polarity and mechanical force in intact tissues was "less certain", they wrote in 2019 [15].
A morphogen in the fly wing (2000–2017). Decapentaplegic (Dpp), a signalling protein of the BMP family, is secreted from a stripe of cells across the developing wing and forms a concentration gradient that patterns the wing and promotes its growth [11, 13], yet cell proliferation is uniform across the tissue [5]. Stephen Day and Peter Lawrence proposed that cells sense the gradient's slope [13]. In 2011 Ortrud Wartlick and colleagues measured Dpp gradients that scale with tissue size and found that, on average, cells divide when their Dpp signalling has risen by 50% [5]. By 2015 the role of the gradient in growth was "highly controversial" [9]. Stefan Harmansa and colleagues trapped Dpp at the cell surface so that it could not spread: patterning was lost, but lateral cells still divided at normal rates, which fits a model in which Dpp is needed only for growth of the central cells and does not fit a global rule based on rising Dpp [9]. In 2017 Pablo Sanchez Bosch and colleagues removed dpp with conditional alleles, found the stripe essential for wing growth, and showed that uniform, low-level Dpp could meet that need but not the need for patterning [11].
Mechanical feedback (2005–2017). Shraiman modelled a growing tissue layer in 2005 and showed that a patch of cells growing faster or slower than its neighbours comes under mechanical stress; he proposed that if division rates depend on local stress, this feedback could keep growth uniform [2]. In 2007 two groups proposed compressive stress as a possible mechanism of size determination in imaginal discs [12]. In 2016 Yuanwang Pan and colleagues found in the fly wing disc that faster-growing cells carry less tension along their junctions, which reduces the activity of Yorkie through the Hippo pathway, and that genetically suppressing this feedback alters the pattern of proliferation [10].
Coordination with the whole body (2012). Two groups reported in 2012 that imaginal discs growing abnormally secrete Dilp8, an insulin-like peptide that delays metamorphosis [6, 7]. Andres Garelli and colleagues found that it also slows disc growth and yields normal-sized animals, and that flies lacking dilp8 are asymmetric and unusually variable in size [6].
Main approaches
Hippo as a size controller. The Hippo pathway limits growth by inactivating Yorkie or YAP; Dong and colleagues described it as "a universal size-control mechanism" [1, 4]. Strongest evidence: overgrowth when Yorkie is overexpressed in flies [1], and reversible enlargement of the mouse liver driven by YAP [4]. Main difficulty: losing Hippo signalling does not enlarge several mouse organs [15], and how upstream signals reach the cascade in intact tissues is not well understood [15].
Rules for reading a morphogen. Cells set their growth from the Dpp gradient, by its slope, its rise over time or a threshold [5, 13]. Strongest evidence: gradients that scale with the disc and the 50% rule [5]. Main difficulty: lateral cells grow normally when Dpp cannot spread [9], uniform low-level Dpp supports growth [11], and Vollmer and colleagues note that because scaling is imperfect, the rule based on rising Dpp would produce "neither uniform growth nor growth termination" [13].
Mechanical feedback. Stress from uneven growth feeds back on growth, evening it out and perhaps ending it [2, 12]. Strongest evidence: the link from junction tension through the Hippo pathway to Yorkie, and altered proliferation when the feedback is suppressed [10]. Main difficulty: Irvine and Shraiman write that "many unanswered questions" remain about how stress arises and relaxes in growing tissue and how it regulates growth, and expect different mechanisms in tissues of several cell layers [12].
Systemic and organ-specific control. Final size depends on nutrition, on hormones that set the duration of growth and on signals between organs, in proportions that differ between organs [8, 12, 13]. Strongest evidence: liver regrowth to a set point and the joined-circulation experiments [8], the spleen grafts [13] and Dilp8 [6, 7]. Main difficulty: the liver's systemic factors are unidentified [8], while salamander grafts kept their donor's size [13] and pancreas size is fixed by progenitor number [3].
Open sub-questions
- Organs that Hippo does not enlarge. In the mouse organs that stay normal in size when Hippo signalling is lost, is final size limited by the progenitor pool, as in the pancreas [3, 15]?
- Growth on uniform Dpp. In wings grown with uniform, low-level Dpp, does growth stop at the normal size and time, and do cells still divide after a fixed relative rise in signalling [5, 11]?
- Mechanics and final size. If the tension-dependent control of Yorkie is blocked throughout the wing disc, does final wing size change, or only the spatial pattern of proliferation [10, 12]?
- The liver's systemic signal. Which circulating factor makes both livers grow after partial removal of one in animals with joined circulations, and is it the same factor that shrinks a liver grafted into a smaller host [8]?
- Thymus versus spleen. What property of the spleen, but not the thymus, lets several grafts regulate their combined mass to that of one organ [13]?
- Triggering Dilp8. Which signal from an abnormally growing disc switches on dilp8, and does the same signal act on small left–right differences in normal development [6, 7]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Huang, J., Wu, S., Barrera, J., Matthews, K. & Pan, D. (2005). The Hippo signaling pathway coordinately regulates cell proliferation and apoptosis by inactivating Yorkie, the Drosophila homolog of YAP. Cell 122(3), 421–434. 10.1016/j.cell.2005.06.007 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Shraiman, B. I. (2005). Mechanical feedback as a possible regulator of tissue growth. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102(9), 3318–3323. 10.1073/pnas.0404782102 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Stanger, B. Z., Tanaka, A. J. & Melton, D. A. (2007). Organ size is limited by the number of embryonic progenitor cells in the pancreas but not the liver. Nature 445(7130), 886–891. 10.1038/nature05537 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Dong, J., Feldmann, G., Huang, J., Wu, S., Zhang, N., Comerford, S. A., Gayyed, M. F., Anders, R. A., Maitra, A. & Pan, D. (2007). Elucidation of a universal size-control mechanism in Drosophila and mammals. Cell 130(6), 1120–1133. 10.1016/j.cell.2007.07.019 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Wartlick, O., Mumcu, P., Kicheva, A., Bittig, T., Seum, C., Jülicher, F. & González-Gaitán, M. (2011). Dynamics of Dpp signaling and proliferation control. Science 331(6021), 1154–1159. 10.1126/science.1200037 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Garelli, A., Gontijo, A. M., Miguela, V., Caparros, E. & Dominguez, M. (2012). Imaginal discs secrete insulin-like peptide 8 to mediate plasticity of growth and maturation. Science 336(6081), 579–582. 10.1126/science.1216735 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Colombani, J., Andersen, D. S. & Léopold, P. (2012). Secreted peptide Dilp8 coordinates Drosophila tissue growth with developmental timing. Science 336(6081), 582–585. 10.1126/science.1216689 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Penzo-Méndez, A. I. & Stanger, B. Z. (2015). Organ-size regulation in mammals. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology 7(9), a019240. 10.1101/cshperspect.a019240 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Harmansa, S., Hamaratoglu, F., Affolter, M. & Caussinus, E. (2015). Dpp spreading is required for medial but not for lateral wing disc growth. Nature 527(7578), 317–322. 10.1038/nature15712 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Pan, Y., Heemskerk, I., Ibar, C., Shraiman, B. I. & Irvine, K. D. (2016). Differential growth triggers mechanical feedback that elevates Hippo signaling. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113(45), E6974–E6983. 10.1073/pnas.1615012113 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Bosch, P. S., Ziukaite, R., Alexandre, C., Basler, K. & Vincent, J.-P. (2017). Dpp controls growth and patterning in Drosophila wing precursors through distinct modes of action. eLife 6, e22546. 10.7554/eLife.22546 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Irvine, K. D. & Shraiman, B. I. (2017). Mechanical control of growth: ideas, facts and challenges. Development 144(23), 4238–4248. 10.1242/dev.151902 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Vollmer, J., Casares, F. & Iber, D. (2017). Growth and size control during development. Open Biology 7(11), 170190. 10.1098/rsob.170190 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Saunders, T. E. & Ingham, P. W. (2019). Open questions: how to get developmental biology into shape? BMC Biology 17(1), 17. 10.1186/s12915-019-0636-6 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Zheng, Y. & Pan, D. (2019). The Hippo signaling pathway in development and disease. Developmental Cell 50(3), 264–282. 10.1016/j.devcel.2019.06.003 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.