Papex

Open problem · Physics · since 1983 · Open

EMC effect

Why do quarks in protons and neutrons bound inside a nucleus behave differently from those in free ones?

Summary

Since 1983, scattering experiments have shown that protons and neutrons inside nuclei have different quark momentum distributions from free ones; many explanations have been proposed, but none has been confirmed.

Why it is open

In 1983 the European Muon Collaboration (EMC) at CERN scattered muons off iron and deuterium and compared their structure functions, which describe the momentum distribution of the quarks in a nucleon [1, 8]. The ratio of iron to deuterium per nucleon varied with Bjorken x, the fraction of the nucleon's momentum carried by the struck quark, in a way "in disagreement with existing theoretical predictions" [1, 8]. Quark interactions take place at shorter distances and higher energies than nuclear interactions, so the internal structure of a nucleon had been expected not to depend on the nucleus around it [8].

The effect has since been confirmed in many nuclei, with both muons and electrons [8]. Of the many explanations proposed soon after the discovery, Anthony Thomas wrote in 2018 that "very few are still widely considered viable" [7]. In 2019 the CLAS Collaboration wrote that "there is still no generally accepted explanation for its cause" [8]. They describe two leading approaches, both consistent with the data: all nucleons are slightly modified when bound in nuclei, or nucleons are unmodified most of the time but modified significantly when they fluctuate into short-range correlated pairs [8].

No body sets a bar for a resolution. The sources point to measurements on which the explanations make different predictions: the spin-dependent EMC effect [7]; deep inelastic scattering tagged by a recoiling nucleon, which relates the modification to the momentum of the struck nucleon [6, 8]; and data from the planned Electron–Ion Collider, which the authors of a 2022 simulation study say "should allow scientists to definitively show" whether the EMC effect and short-range correlations are connected [10].

The collaboration's 1988 measurement with polarised muons and protons, which concluded that "the total quark spin constitutes a rather small fraction of the spin of the nucleon" [2], belongs to a different open question, the proton spin crisis [6].

What is known

Discovery and nuclear dependence (1983–1994). The EMC measured the ratio of the structure function per nucleon in iron to that in deuterium using deep inelastic scattering, in which a lepton transfers enough energy and momentum to resolve individual quarks [1, 8]. The CLAS Collaboration summarises the result as a decrease of the ratio in the region of moderate- to high-momentum quarks [8]. At the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), experiment E139 measured deep inelastic electron scattering from deuterium, helium-4, beryllium, carbon, aluminium, calcium, iron, silver and gold, for x from 0.089 to 0.8 [3, 12]. The per-nucleon ratios to deuterium were greater than one for x between 0.1 and 0.3 and less than one for x between 0.3 and 0.8, where they decreased logarithmically with atomic weight A, or linearly with average nuclear density; no dependence on momentum transfer was seen [3]. According to CLAS, the largest reduction relative to deuterium grows from about 10% for helium-4 to about 20% for gold [8].

Light nuclei (2009–2023). At Jefferson Lab (JLab), Seely and colleagues measured helium-3, helium-4, beryllium-9 and carbon-12; their data "do not support previous A-dependent or density-dependent fits" and suggest that the nuclear dependence "may depend on the local nuclear environment" [4]. In 2023 the first measurements in boron-10 and boron-11 found an effect similar to that in beryllium-9 and carbon-12, "almost no nuclear dependence" between A = 4 and 12, which the authors read as support for the hypothesis that the effect depends primarily on the local nuclear environment, because of the cluster structure of these nuclei [11].

Short-range correlations (2011–2019). Short-range correlated (SRC) pairs are brief fluctuations in which two nucleons come close together and interact strongly, moving them from shell-model states into a high-momentum tail [8]. In 2011 Weinstein and colleagues showed that the size of the EMC effect for 0.35 ≤ x ≤ 0.7 is linearly related to the SRC scaling factor measured at x ≥ 1, and speculated that both are dominated by high-momentum nucleons [5]. A 2017 review by Or Hen, Gerald Miller, Eli Piasetzky and Lawrence Weinstein concluded that the relation "is not an accident" and that correlated neutron–proton pairs are responsible for both effects, adding that the conclusion "needs to be solidified by the future experiments" [6]. In 2019 CLAS measured both effects together in carbon, aluminium, iron and lead relative to deuterium, the first EMC measurement in lead, and showed that the data "can be explained by a universal modification" of the structure of nucleons in neutron–proton SRC pairs [8]. Their model predicts that the effect per proton keeps growing with A while the effect per neutron stops growing near A = 12, a pattern they report the data support [8].

Challenges and three-nucleon data (2018–2026). Thomas wrote in 2018 that the quark–meson coupling model, a mean-field model, describes the EMC effect "quantitatively across the periodic table", while the predictive capacity of the SRC idea "is much less developed" [7]. In 2020 Wang, Thomas and Melnitchouk found in model calculations for the deuteron that the effect of Fermi motion (the motion of nucleons inside the nucleus) "overwhelms the off-shell effects for nucleons in short-range correlations", where off-shell means that a bound nucleon's energy and momentum do not satisfy the relation for a free one; they say this calls a causal link into question [9]. In 2025 the MARATHON experiment at JLab reported the first EMC measurement in tritium, together with helium-3 [12]. The authors found the combined A = 3 result consistent with the SLAC parametrisation from heavier nuclei and in agreement with models in which the corrections come from the energy and momentum of bound nucleons plus an off-shell modification of their structure; the data gave no evidence for a sizable isovector component, one that differs between protons and neutrons, which an earlier analysis had argued for [12]. A 2026 global analysis by Cocuzza and colleagues that includes the MARATHON data found strong evidence that off-shell corrections are needed, "a suggestion of nonzero isovector contributions" in nuclei with A ≤ 3, and ratios of nuclear to nucleon structure functions for A = 2 and 3 that differ from those naively extrapolated from heavy nuclei [13].

Main approaches

Mean-field modification. Every bound nucleon is changed slightly: in the quark–meson coupling model, the strong scalar mean field of the nucleus alters the confined quarks [7]. Strongest evidence: applications of the model over 30 years describe the effect across the periodic table [7], and a deuteron calculation questions the alternative [9]. Main difficulty: both leading pictures fit the unpolarised data [8], so Thomas calls for "new, as yet unobserved phenomena" on which they make definite predictions [7].

Modification in correlated pairs. Nucleons are unmodified most of the time and change strongly while in an SRC pair [8]. Strongest evidence: the linear EMC–SRC relation [5] and the universal modification function with its per-proton and per-neutron pattern [8]. Main difficulty: the idea's predictive capacity is "much less developed" [7], and Fermi motion may outweigh off-shell effects in the deuteron [9]; its proponents call for further experiments [6].

Binding and off-shell corrections. Describe the effect through the energy and momentum of bound nucleons plus an off-shell modification of their structure, and fit parton distributions and off-shell corrections together without assuming how nuclear effects depend on isospin [12, 13]. Strongest evidence: the three-nucleon data agree with such models [12], and the global analysis finds strong evidence that off-shell corrections are needed [13]. Main difficulty: whether an isovector part exists is unsettled: MARATHON found no evidence for a sizable one [12], while the 2026 analysis finds a suggestion of one [13].

Discriminating measurements. Tagging a spectator nucleon fixes the struck nucleon's initial momentum, so its structure can be measured as a function of momentum; the 2017 review lists two approved JLab experiments, E12-11-107 and E12-11-003A, and a first measurement of the spin-dependent effect in lithium-7 [6]. Thomas expects little or no spin-dependent EMC effect if SRCs were its sole source [7]. Strongest evidence: simulations show that the Electron–Ion Collider could detect knocked-out and recoiling nucleons over a wide range of initial momenta [10]. Main difficulty: fragments of the struck nucleon may break up other SRC pairs as they leave the nucleus, which the review names as a major uncertainty in interpreting tagged measurements [6]; the polarised measurement is "difficult" [7].

Open sub-questions

  1. Momentum dependence. In deep inelastic scattering on the deuteron tagged by a backward spectator nucleon, how does the structure-function modification depend on the struck nucleon's initial momentum, and does it match the universal SRC-pair modification function extracted from inclusive data [6, 8]?
  2. Spin in lithium-7. Is the spin-dependent EMC effect in lithium-7 close to the spin-independent one, as the mean-field prediction suggests, or near zero, as Thomas expects if SRCs were the sole source [7]?
  3. Isovector part. Do further three-nucleon or neutron-rich data confirm or exclude the nonzero isovector off-shell contribution suggested by the 2026 global analysis [12, 13]?
  4. Clusters. Does a measure of local density from cluster structure predict the EMC effect in light nuclei better than SRC abundance, for example in beryllium-9 and the boron isotopes [4, 11]?
  5. Per-neutron saturation. In isospin-asymmetric pairs such as calcium-48 and calcium-40, does the per-neutron EMC effect stay flat above A = 12 while the per-proton effect grows, as the 2019 SRC model predicts [6, 8]?

Work on this in Papex

If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.

Key references

  1. Aubert, J. J., Bassompierre, G., Becks, K. H., Best, C., Böhm, E., de Bouard, X. et al. (European Muon Collaboration) (1983). The ratio of the nucleon structure functions F2N for iron and deuterium. Physics Letters B 123(3–4), 275–278. 10.1016/0370-2693(83)90437-9 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  2. Ashman, J., Badelek, B., Baum, G., Beaufays, J., Bee, C. P., Benchouk, C. et al. (European Muon Collaboration) (1988). A measurement of the spin asymmetry and determination of the structure function g1 in deep inelastic muon-proton scattering. Physics Letters B 206(2), 364–370. 10.1016/0370-2693(88)91523-7 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  3. Gomez, J., Arnold, R. G., Bosted, P. E., Chang, C. C., Katramatou, A. T., Petratos, G. G. et al. (1994). Measurement of the A dependence of deep-inelastic electron scattering. Physical Review D 49(9), 4348–4372. 10.1103/PhysRevD.49.4348 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  4. Seely, J., Daniel, A., Gaskell, D., Arrington, J., Fomin, N., Solvignon, P. et al. (2009). New measurements of the European Muon Collaboration effect in very light nuclei. Physical Review Letters 103(20), 202301. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.103.202301 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  5. Weinstein, L. B., Piasetzky, E., Higinbotham, D. W., Gomez, J., Hen, O. & Shneor, R. (2011). Short range correlations and the EMC effect. Physical Review Letters 106(5), 052301. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.052301 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  6. Hen, O., Miller, G. A., Piasetzky, E. & Weinstein, L. B. (2017). Nucleon-nucleon correlations, short-lived excitations, and the quarks within. Reviews of Modern Physics 89(4), 045002. 10.1103/RevModPhys.89.045002 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  7. Thomas, A. W. (2018). Reflections on the origin of the EMC effect. International Journal of Modern Physics E 27(12), 1840001 (issue of December 2018, published online 27 March 2019). 10.1142/S0218301318400013 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  8. Schmookler, B., Duer, M., Schmidt, A., Hen, O., Gilad, S., Piasetzky, E. et al. (CLAS Collaboration) (2019). Modified structure of protons and neutrons in correlated pairs. Nature 566(7744), 354–358. 10.1038/s41586-019-0925-9 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  9. Wang, X. G., Thomas, A. W. & Melnitchouk, W. (2020). Do short-range correlations cause the nuclear EMC effect in the deuteron? Physical Review Letters 125(26), 262002. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.262002 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  10. Hauenstein, F., Jentsch, A., Pybus, J. R., Kiral, A., Baker, M. D., Furletova, Y. et al. (2022). Measuring recoiling nucleons from the nucleus with the future Electron Ion Collider. Physical Review C 105(3), 034001. 10.1103/PhysRevC.105.034001 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  11. Karki, A., Biswas, D., Gonzalez, F. A., Henry, W., Morean, C., Nadeeshani, A. et al. (2023). First measurement of the EMC effect in 10B and 11B. Physical Review C 108(3), 035201. 10.1103/PhysRevC.108.035201 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  12. Abrams, D., Albataineh, H., Aljawrneh, B. S., Alsalmi, S., Androic, D., Aniol, K. et al. (Jefferson Lab Hall A Tritium Collaboration) (2025). EMC effect of tritium and helium-3 from the JLab MARATHON experiment. Physical Review Letters 135(6), 062502. 10.1103/31xz-s84d · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  13. Cocuzza, C., Hague, T. J., Melnitchouk, W., Sato, N. & Thomas, A. W. (JAM Collaboration) (2026). Isospin dependence of the nuclear EMC effect from a global QCD analysis. Physical Review D 114(5), 054004. 10.1103/trd9-gtnr · Checked 16 Oct 2026

Page reviewed 16 Oct 2026

Source

Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in physics. Checked 08 Oct 2026.

The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.

Records on this problem

No public record addresses this problem yet.

More in Physics