Papex

Open problem · Physics · since 1987 · Open

Proton spin crisis

How do the proton’s quarks and gluons add up to give it its spin?

Summary

A 1987 experiment by the European Muon Collaboration found that quark spins carry only a small fraction of the proton’s spin, against expectations; how the spin is shared among quarks, gluons and their orbital motion is not settled.

Why it is open

In the non-relativistic quark model, three quarks sit in s-wave orbits (states without orbital angular momentum) and their spins combine to one-half [10]. The European Muon Collaboration (EMC) tested this picture by scattering longitudinally polarised muons off longitudinally polarised protons [1, 10]. It found the integral of the spin-dependent structure function g1 to be 0.114 ± 0.012 ± 0.026, in disagreement with the Ellis–Jaffe sum rule, and concluded that "the total quark spin constitutes a rather small fraction of the spin of the nucleon" [1]. Xiangdong Ji, Feng Yuan and Yong Zhao date the measurement to 1987 and give the quark spin fraction as 0.060 ± 0.047 ± 0.069, "consistent with zero", a result that created the proton spin "crisis" [10]. The collaboration's other well-known result, the EMC effect, is a separate problem.

Since then the question has been how the spin divides, which depends on how it is split. Ji's decomposition, ½ΔΣ + L_q + J_g = ½, uses gauge-invariant terms (unchanged by the gauge transformations of the theory of quarks and gluons) and holds in any reference frame; ΔΣ is the quark spin contribution, L_q the quark orbital angular momentum and J_g the whole gluon contribution [3, 10]. Robert Jaffe and Aneesh Manohar's decomposition, ½ΔΣ + ΔG + ℓ_q + ℓ_g = ½, separates the gluon spin ΔG from quark and gluon orbital terms and has a simple parton interpretation for a proton moving at nearly the speed of light [2, 10]. The orbital terms of the two schemes differ, and every term depends on the renormalisation scheme and scale [10]. Elliot Leader and Cédric Lorcé conclude that such a decomposition "is not unique" and that the choice of one is "essentially a matter of taste and convenience" [4].

No body sets a bar for a resolution. The sources point to what is missing: the gluon spin at small momentum fractions [5, 10], measured quark and gluon orbital terms [7, 10], and lattice calculations of every term with controlled uncertainties [10, 13].

What is known

Quark spin (1988–2020). Deep inelastic scattering experiments after the EMC determined the total quark spin contribution well: global analyses give ΔΣ ≈ 0.30, with uncertainties around 0.10 [10]. The polarisation of the sea quarks (quark–antiquark pairs), in particular strange quarks, is less certain [10]. Lattice calculations have consistently found the quark spin to give about 40% of the proton spin [10].

Gluon spin from RHIC (2014–2026). Brookhaven's Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) collided polarised protons [10]. The STAR experiment's jet asymmetries "provide evidence for positive gluon polarization" for gluons carrying more than 5% of the proton's momentum (x > 0.05) [6]. Using RHIC data from the 2009 run, Daniel de Florian, Rodolfo Sassot, Marco Stratmann and Werner Vogelsang found "clear evidence for a non-vanishing polarization of gluons" in the range probed [5]; Ji and colleagues quote their integral of the gluon helicity distribution over x > 0.05 as 0.20 (+0.06, −0.07) [10]. Below x = 0.05 the uncertainty "is still very significant" [5]. In 2022 Yiyu Zhou, Nobuo Sato and Wally Melnitchouk showed that, without requiring parton distributions to be positive, the data allow negative as well as positive gluon polarisation, "giving equally acceptable descriptions of the data" [11]. In 2024 Nicholas Hunt-Smith and colleagues added deep inelastic data at large x and lattice data, and found that the negative solutions "cannot simultaneously account for" all of these together with the jet data; they call further tests "desirable" [12]. RHIC's final collisions took place on 6 February 2026, and its last run yielded proton–proton collisions that will provide "insight into proton spin" [14].

Lattice QCD (2017–2025). Lattice QCD computes the proton's properties by simulating quarks and gluons on a four-dimensional space-time grid [10]. At the physical pion mass, Constantia Alexandrou and colleagues found a quark spin contribution of 0.191(15), a total quark angular momentum of 0.285(45) and a gluon angular momentum of 0.187(46), summing to 0.473(71), "confirming the spin sum", all in the MS-bar scheme at 2 GeV [9]. Ji and colleagues read this as about 18.8% of the spin from quark orbital motion [10]. The gluon spin is harder, because it is defined through light-front correlations with real-time dynamics, which Monte Carlo simulations handle only at exponentially growing cost; large-momentum effective theory (LaMET) relates it to quantities computed on the lattice in a fast-moving proton [10]. In 2017 Yi-Bo Yang and colleagues obtained 0.251(47)(16) at a scale μ² = 10 GeV² for the glue spin, which equals ΔG if a matching step is neglected [8]. Dian-Jun Zhao and colleagues note that the one-loop renormalisation used there "introduces a large correction" [13]. In a December 2025 preprint they report ΔG = 0.231(17)(44) at the same scale, extrapolated to zero lattice spacing, or about 46(9)% of the proton spin, and write that this "clearly rules out the possibility of a negative gluon helicity contribution" [13]. The preprint had no journal reference on 16 October 2026 [13].

Orbital motion. Ji showed that the total quark contribution, and so the quark orbital part, can be measured through deeply virtual Compton scattering (DVCS), in which a lepton scatters off a proton and produces an energetic photon [3, 10]. DVCS data from Jefferson Lab and the HERMES experiment "suggest a substantial quark orbital contribution", with constraints that depend on models [10]. The orbital terms of Jaffe and Manohar are harder to reach: their distributions are sub-leading in high-energy experiments and may carry a contribution at x = 0 that makes measuring them through sum rules challenging [10].

Main approaches

Gluon spin over the full range of x. Measure the gluon helicity distribution and integrate it to obtain ΔG [5]. Strongest evidence: RHIC jet asymmetries, which standard fits read as positive gluon polarisation for x > 0.05 [5, 6]. Main difficulty: the region below x = 0.05 is poorly constrained [5], and the evidence against a negative sign at moderate x draws on large-x deep inelastic data, together with lattice and jet data,, which the authors note are sensitive to power corrections [11, 12].

Angular momentum from generalised parton distributions. In Ji's scheme the quark and gluon angular momenta are moments of generalised parton distributions (GPDs), which describe how partons are distributed in both momentum and position, measured in DVCS and related processes [3, 10]. Strongest evidence: existing DVCS data show strong sensitivity to quark orbital motion [10]. Main difficulty: little is known about the GPD E needed for the angular momentum, and extracting it calls for more sophisticated parametrisations and a joint analysis of many data sets [10].

Lattice QCD. Compute every term from first principles [10]. Strongest evidence: a full decomposition at the physical pion mass that adds up to the proton spin within its uncertainty [9], and a gluon spin extrapolated to zero lattice spacing [13]. Main difficulty: the calculation needs costly disconnected diagrams and noisy gluon observables [10], and Zhao and colleagues write that the LaMET factorisation for ΔG was found to be incompatible with that for the gluon helicity distribution, which their method is designed to avoid [13].

An electron–ion collider. Polarised electron–proton collisions over a wide range of x and momentum transfer would constrain ΔΣ and ΔG, and so, by subtraction from ½, "the total contribution of quark and gluon orbital momenta" [7]. The collider may also give direct access to gluon orbital motion through hard diffractive dijet production [10]. Strongest evidence: simulated EIC data shrink the uncertainties on ΔΣ and the gluon spin in global fits [7]. Main difficulty: the Electron–Ion Collider at Brookhaven is not yet built; on 6 February 2026 the US Department of Energy approved a second phase of long-lead purchases "as the EIC transitions into construction" [15].

Open sub-questions

  1. Small-x gluon spin. How much of ΔG lies below x = 0.05, and how far would EIC data at the highest collision energy narrow it [5, 7]?
  2. An independent sign test. Does an observable outside large-x deep inelastic scattering, such as RHIC dijet asymmetries, reject the negative gluon solutions on its own [11, 12]?
  3. Lattice against experiment. Is the continuum lattice ΔG of 0.231(17)(44) consistent with global fits once their small-x region is included [10, 13]?
  4. Quark orbital motion. Can Jefferson Lab 12 GeV DVCS data fix L_q without model assumptions, for comparison with the lattice value [9, 10]?
  5. Two kinds of orbital motion. How large is the difference between Ji's and Jaffe–Manohar's quark orbital terms in the proton [4, 10]?
  6. Gluon orbital motion. Is the target-spin asymmetry in hard diffractive dijet production large enough to measure ℓ_g at the EIC [10]?

Work on this in Papex

If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.

Key references

  1. Ashman, J., Badelek, B., Baum, G., Beaufays, J., Bee, C. P., Benchouk, C. et al. (European Muon Collaboration) (1988). A measurement of the spin asymmetry and determination of the structure function g1 in deep inelastic muon-proton scattering. Physics Letters B 206(2), 364–370. 10.1016/0370-2693(88)91523-7 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  2. Jaffe, R. L. & Manohar, A. (1990). The g1 problem: deep inelastic electron scattering and the spin of the proton. Nuclear Physics B 337(3), 509–546. 10.1016/0550-3213(90)90506-9 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  3. Ji, X. (1997). Gauge-invariant decomposition of nucleon spin. Physical Review Letters 78(4), 610–613. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.610 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  4. Leader, E. & Lorcé, C. (2014). The angular momentum controversy: what's it all about and does it matter? Physics Reports 541(3), 163–248; erratum 2019, DOI 10.1016/j.physrep.2019.01.006, not read. 10.1016/j.physrep.2014.02.010 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  5. de Florian, D., Sassot, R., Stratmann, M. & Vogelsang, W. (2014). Evidence for polarization of gluons in the proton. Physical Review Letters 113(1), 012001. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.113.012001 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  6. Adamczyk, L., Adkins, J. K., Agakishiev, G., Aggarwal, M. M., Ahammed, Z., Alekseev, I. et al. (STAR Collaboration) (2015). Precision measurement of the longitudinal double-spin asymmetry for inclusive jet production in polarized proton collisions at √s = 200 GeV. Physical Review Letters 115(9), 092002. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.092002 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  7. Accardi, A., Albacete, J. L., Anselmino, M., Armesto, N., Aschenauer, E. C., Bacchetta, A. et al. (2016). Electron-Ion Collider: the next QCD frontier. The European Physical Journal A 52(9), 268. 10.1140/epja/i2016-16268-9 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  8. Yang, Y.-B., Sufian, R. S., Alexandru, A., Draper, T., Glatzmaier, M. J., Liu, K.-F. & Zhao, Y. (χQCD Collaboration) (2017). Glue spin and helicity in the proton from lattice QCD. Physical Review Letters 118(10), 102001. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.102001 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  9. Alexandrou, C., Bacchio, S., Constantinou, M., Finkenrath, J., Hadjiyiannakou, K., Jansen, K. et al. (2020). Complete flavor decomposition of the spin and momentum fraction of the proton using lattice QCD simulations at physical pion mass. Physical Review D 101(9), 094513. 10.1103/PhysRevD.101.094513 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  10. Ji, X., Yuan, F. & Zhao, Y. (2021). What we know and what we don't know about the proton spin after 30 years. Nature Reviews Physics 3(1), 27–38 (published online 2020); correction 2020, DOI 10.1038/s42254-020-00274-2, not read. 10.1038/s42254-020-00248-4 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  11. Zhou, Y., Sato, N. & Melnitchouk, W. (2022). How well do we know the gluon polarization in the proton? Physical Review D 105(7), 074022. 10.1103/PhysRevD.105.074022 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  12. Hunt-Smith, N. T., Cocuzza, C., Melnitchouk, W., Sato, N., Thomas, A. W. & White, M. J. (2024). New data-driven constraints on the sign of gluon polarization in the proton. Physical Review Letters 133(16), 161901. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.161901 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  13. Zhao, D.-J., Chen, L., Dong, H., Ji, X., Liu, L., Pang, Z. et al. (2025). Total gluon helicity contribution to the proton spin from lattice QCD. Preprint, arXiv:2512.24315 (version 2, 16 January 2026), not peer reviewed. Source · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  14. Brookhaven National Laboratory (2026). A smashing success: Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider wraps up final collisions. News release, 6 February 2026. Source · Checked 16 Oct 2026
  15. Brookhaven National Laboratory (2026). DOE approves next phase of funding for Electron-Ion Collider. News release, 6 February 2026. Source · Checked 16 Oct 2026

Page reviewed 16 Oct 2026

Source

Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in physics. Checked 08 Oct 2026.

The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.

Records on this problem

No public record addresses this problem yet.

More in Physics