Darwin’s abominable mystery
Why do flowering plants appear so suddenly, and nearly modern, in the fossil record?
Summary
Why it is open
In a letter of 22 July 1879 to the botanist Joseph Hooker, Charles Darwin wrote: "The rapid development, as far as we can judge, of all the higher plants within recent geological times is an abominable mystery" [1]. He floated a long hidden history on "a small isolated continent in the S. hemisphere" and called it "a wretchedly poor conjecture" [1]. From Darwin's letters of 1875 to 1881, William Friedman argues that what troubled Darwin was "an abrupt origin and highly accelerated rate of diversification of flowering plants in the mid-Cretaceous", for Darwin the most extreme exception to his view that nature does not make leaps [2].
The modern problem is several questions. Hervé Sauquet, Santiago Ramírez-Barahona and Susana Magallón separate three ages: the stem age, when the angiosperm lineage split from living gymnosperms; the morphological age, when flowers and other distinctive features arose; and the crown age, of the most recent common ancestor of all living angiosperms [13]. Published crown ages run "from ~140 million years (Ma; Early Cretaceous) to 270 Ma (Permian)", and they propose that the age "is best described as largely unknown (140-270 Ma)" [13]. Separate questions are why the fossils appear so abruptly and what caused the radiation that followed.
No body sets a bar for a resolution. On the fossil side, Patrick Herendeen and colleagues write that credible evidence of older angiosperms "will require unambiguous documentation of the diagnostic structural features" separating them from other seed plants [4]; Richard Bateman names the most reliable candidates (double fertilisation, a closed carpel, an ovule with two coats and phloem companion cells) and notes that they are rarely preserved or hard to detect unambiguously [10]. On the molecular side, Sauquet and colleagues argue that the clock estimate of the crown age "is almost entirely conditioned by its own prior distribution", the calibration density chosen by the analyst [13].
What is known
The fossil record (to 2019). Reviews more than half a century old found that angiosperms are richly represented in Late Cretaceous and younger sediments but have no reliable pre-Cretaceous records; Herendeen, Else Marie Friis, Kaj Raunsgaard Pedersen and Peter Crane write that the macrofossil, mesofossil and microfossil data gathered since "have confirmed and reinforced this pattern" [4]. Mario Coiro, James Doyle and Jason Hilton describe pollen floras recording the appearance of angiosperms in northern Gondwana in the Valanginian stage of the Early Cretaceous and a later spread towards the poles, including eudicot pollen, that accelerated in the Albian [9]. That sequence matches molecular inferences on how pollen evolved but "conflicts strongly with Triassic and early Jurassic molecular ages", and the discrepancy is hard to explain by geographic or preservation biases [9]. Pollen with some crown-angiosperm characters is known from the Middle Triassic, but it is difficult to tell apart from pollen of stem relatives of angiosperms or of gymnosperms [5]. The Early Cretaceous radiation involves "only lineages closely similar to extant taxonomic families" and "lacks obvious morphological gaps", Bateman writes [10].
Molecular clocks (2018–2024). Jose Barba-Montoya and colleagues analysed 83 genes from 644 taxa with 52 fossil calibrations [5]. Their first calibration strategy placed crown angiosperms at 255–206 million years ago; even an "unrealistically optimistic" maximum of 139.4 million years gave 162–149 million years, still older than the earliest unequivocal fossils [5]. They reject a post-Jurassic origin, but conclude that the hidden early history "may be as much as 121 Myr, or as little as 23 Myr" and that the conflict with fossils "may be a consequence of false precision on both sides" [5]. In 2024 Alexandre Zuntini and colleagues dated a tree of almost 8,000 genera built from 353 nuclear genes, with 200 fossil calibrations and two alternative maximum ages for the crown node, 154 and 247 million years [15]. Early evolution was an explosive burst of diversification that gave rise to more than 80% of living orders; with the younger maximum the burst falls in the Cretaceous, with the older in the Triassic, "dramatically at variance with the palaeobotanical record", which shows that current dating methods "are unable to resolve the age of angiosperms" [15].
Statistics on fossil occurrences (2021). Daniele Silvestro and colleagues estimated family ages from about 15,000 fossil occurrences in 198 families; several families originated in the Jurassic, "strongly rejecting a Cretaceous origin", with a marked rise in lineage accumulation from 125 to 72 million years ago [11]. Graham Budd and colleagues replied in a 2021 preprint, not peer reviewed and with no published version listed on 16 October 2026, that the results "strongly conflict with the known temporal distribution of angiosperm fossils" and that the conclusions "are unsound" [12].
Recent claims: a Jurassic flower (2018–2023). In December 2018 in eLife, Qiang Fu and colleagues described Nanjinganthus dendrostyla from 264 specimens of 198 flowers in the Early Jurassic South Xiangshan Formation of China, inferring enclosed seeds and calling it consistent with "a bona fide angiosperm from the Jurassic" [7]. In a commentary in the same journal, David Winship Taylor and Hongqi Li concluded that "the evidence suggests that it is a Jurassic flowering plant", but that "additional characteristics need to be documented" and its relationships analysed phylogenetically [8]. In the debate that followed [14], reviews in 2019 judged that supposed pre-Cretaceous angiosperms "either represent other plant groups or lack features that might confidently assign them to the angiosperms" [9], and that all are "assignable to other major clades among the gymnosperms sensu lato" [10]. In 2023 Fu and colleagues reported micro-CT (X-ray tomography) images of ovules inside intact, closed ovaries, and maintained that Nanjinganthus "is an Early Jurassic angiosperm" [14].
Main approaches
A hidden pre-Cretaceous history. Crown angiosperms arose in the Jurassic or earlier and left few or unrecognised fossils [5, 11]. Strongest evidence: clock analyses reject a post-Jurassic origin even under an optimistic maximum [5], and an occurrence-based fossil analysis points the same way [11]. Main difficulty: the pollen sequence conflicts with Triassic and early Jurassic ages, though it may allow ecologically restricted Late Jurassic angiosperms [9]; the clock estimate largely reflects its prior [13]; and the fossil analysis is disputed [12].
A Cretaceous origin and primary radiation. Some read the fossil record literally, as an explosive radiation from a Cretaceous ancestor [5, 10]. Strongest evidence: the absence of reliable pre-Cretaceous records despite much new data [4], and a radiation without obvious morphological gaps that Bateman reads as "a primary radiation" [10]. Main difficulty: even the youngest clock estimates remain pre-Cretaceous [5, 15], and Jurassic candidates continue to be proposed [7, 14].
Coevolution with animals. Darwin reported Gaston de Saporta's view that the higher plants developed rapidly "as soon flower-frequenting insects were developed & favoured intercrossing" [1]. Strongest evidence: the fossil record shows a Cretaceous Terrestrial Revolution in which pollinators, herbivores and predators underwent "explosive co-diversification" with angiosperms, and clock analyses remain compatible with it [5]. Main difficulty: coevolution has been invoked mainly for the high diversity of angiosperms, while their ability to outcompete the previously dominant ferns and gymnosperms has been the subject of many other hypotheses [6].
Physiology and feedback. Traits of the plants themselves let them take over [3, 6]. Frank Berendse and Marten Scheffer propose that early angiosperms, confined to disturbed, aquatic or very dry sites, grew faster and made litter that decomposed more easily, a feedback that could run away once they were common enough [3]. Kevin Simonin and Adam Roddy found that only angiosperm lineages underwent rapid genome downsizing in the Early Cretaceous, allowing smaller cells and leaves packed with more veins and stomata [6]. Strongest evidence: across almost 400 living species of ferns, gymnosperms and angiosperms, genome size strongly predicted guard-cell size and stomatal and vein densities, and reconstructions through time show a sudden change in these traits only in Cretaceous angiosperms [6]. Main difficulty: the reconstructed vein densities match fossil data, but too few data on Cretaceous angiosperm stomata exist for the same check [6]; the support for the nutrient feedback comes from modern vegetation shifts, experiments and models, and shows that such a transition is possible rather than that it happened [3].
Open sub-questions
- Scoring Nanjinganthus. Can the characters Bateman lists be scored in the specimens imaged by micro-CT, and where does a phylogenetic analysis then place the fossil [8, 10, 14]?
- Prior sensitivity. How far does the crown age in Zuntini's 353-gene tree move under maximum ages between 154 and 247 million years, and does any calibration escape domination by the prior [13, 15]?
- Restricted Jurassic angiosperms. Would intensive sampling of Late Jurassic sediments in northern Gondwana recover angiosperm pollen if ecologically restricted angiosperms lived there [9]?
- Disputed fossil statistics. Does Silvestro's method still reject a Cretaceous origin when restricted to the fossils and assignments Budd and colleagues accept [11, 12]?
- Genome size and timing. Does genome downsizing coincide with the early burst in Zuntini's younger or older tree [6, 15]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- Darwin, C. R. (1879). Letter to J. D. Hooker, 22 July [1879]. Darwin Correspondence Project, letter no. DCP-LETT-12167 (source: DAR 95: 485–8). Source · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Friedman, W. E. (2009). The meaning of Darwin's "abominable mystery". American Journal of Botany 96(1), 5–21. 10.3732/ajb.0800150 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Berendse, F. & Scheffer, M. (2009). The angiosperm radiation revisited, an ecological explanation for Darwin's 'abominable mystery'. Ecology Letters 12(9), 865–872. 10.1111/j.1461-0248.2009.01342.x · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Herendeen, P. S., Friis, E. M., Pedersen, K. R. & Crane, P. R. (2017). Palaeobotanical redux: revisiting the age of the angiosperms. Nature Plants 3(3), 17015. 10.1038/nplants.2017.15 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Barba-Montoya, J., dos Reis, M., Schneider, H., Donoghue, P. C. J. & Yang, Z. (2018). Constraining uncertainty in the timescale of angiosperm evolution and the veracity of a Cretaceous Terrestrial Revolution. New Phytologist 218(2), 819–834. 10.1111/nph.15011 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Simonin, K. A. & Roddy, A. B. (2018). Genome downsizing, physiological novelty, and the global dominance of flowering plants. PLOS Biology 16(1), e2003706. 10.1371/journal.pbio.2003706 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Fu, Q., Diez, J. B., Pole, M., García Ávila, M., Liu, Z.-J., Chu, H. et al. (2018). An unexpected noncarpellate epigynous flower from the Jurassic of China. eLife 7, e38827. 10.7554/eLife.38827 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Taylor, D. W. & Li, H. (2018). Did flowering plants exist in the Jurassic period? eLife 7, e43421 (Insight on reference 7). 10.7554/eLife.43421 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Coiro, M., Doyle, J. A. & Hilton, J. (2019). How deep is the conflict between molecular and fossil evidence on the age of angiosperms? New Phytologist 223(1), 83–99. 10.1111/nph.15708 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Bateman, R. M. (2020). Hunting the Snark: the flawed search for mythical Jurassic angiosperms. Journal of Experimental Botany 71(1), 22–35 (published online 2019). 10.1093/jxb/erz411 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Silvestro, D., Bacon, C. D., Ding, W., Zhang, Q., Donoghue, P. C. J., Antonelli, A. & Xing, Y. (2021). Fossil data support a pre-Cretaceous origin of flowering plants. Nature Ecology & Evolution 5(4), 449–457. 10.1038/s41559-020-01387-8 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Budd, G. E., Mann, R. P., Doyle, J. A., Coiro, M. P. & Hilton, J. (2021). Fossil data do not support a long pre-Cretaceous history of flowering plants. Preprint, bioRxiv 2021.02.16.431478 (version 1, 17 February 2021), not peer reviewed. 10.1101/2021.02.16.431478 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Sauquet, H., Ramírez-Barahona, S. & Magallón, S. (2022). What is the age of flowering plants? Journal of Experimental Botany 73(12), 3840–3853. 10.1093/jxb/erac130 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Fu, Q., Hou, Y., Yin, P., Diez, J. B., Pole, M., García-Ávila, M. & Wang, X. (2023). Micro-CT results exhibit ovules enclosed in the ovaries of Nanjinganthus. Scientific Reports 13, 426. 10.1038/s41598-022-27334-0 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
- Zuntini, A. R., Carruthers, T., Maurin, O., Bailey, P. C., Leempoel, K., Brewer, G. E. et al. (2024). Phylogenomics and the rise of the angiosperms. Nature 629(8013), 843–850. 10.1038/s41586-024-07324-0 · Checked 16 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 29 Sep 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.