Papex

Open problem · Biology · Open

Evolution of sexual reproduction

Why did sexual reproduction evolve, and why does it persist?

Summary

Asexual reproduction appears to have clear advantages, yet sex dominates among multicellular life; the selective forces behind its origin and its maintenance are unresolved.

Why it is open

Sexual reproduction is almost ubiquitous among living eukaryotes, and abandoning it is commonly regarded as an evolutionary dead end [12]; how eukaryotic cells themselves arose is a separate Papex problem, the origin of eukaryotes. Yet sex is costly. A female that reproduces asexually produces no sons, so, all else being equal, she has twice as many daughters and four times as many granddaughters as the average sexual female, and her clone should rapidly replace the sexual population unless something counteracts it [8]. This reasoning led John Maynard Smith in 1971 to ask "what use is sex?" [8]. The cost is twofold in species with separate sexes and equal investment in sons and daughters, 1.5-fold in hermaphrodites that invest equally in male and female gametes, and smaller with inbreeding or local mate competition; it is "paid" only where an asexual alternative exists [8].

Benefits large enough to pay this cost have been hard to show. In 1990 William Hamilton, Robert Axelrod and Reiko Tanese wrote that "Darwinian theory has yet to explain adequately the fact of sex" [3]. In 2002 Sarah Otto and Thomas Lenormand noted that a large body of theory found that sex and recombination (the reshuffling of genes between chromosomes when eggs and sperm are made) should evolve only under a restricted set of conditions, and suggested that models had ignored genetic drift and the spatial structure of populations [7].

No body sets a bar for a resolution. Each hypothesis sets its own test: the parasite hypothesis needs competing sexual and asexual lineages attacked by natural parasites [8], and the mutation hypothesis needs a high enough rate of harmful mutation [6]. The tests below concern maintenance, whether sex once present resists replacement [8, 9]; Joseph Felsenstein argued that the advantage of recombination could account for its persistence and possibly for its origin [1].

What is known

Parasites (1990–2011). In a model, Hamilton and colleagues found that sex helps hosts recombine defences against many parasites, and that it can remain stable "even while sex pays the full 2-fold cost" [3]. In the New Zealand freshwater snail Potamopyrgus antipodarum, asexual populations prevail where the risk of infection by sterilising trematode worms is low, and some populations mix sexual and asexual snails [8]. In one mixed population, Jukka Jokela, Mark Dybdahl and Curtis Lively found that within 7–10 years the most common clones were almost completely replaced by initially rare clones in two habitats, while sexual snails persisted; the common clones, initially more resistant, became more susceptible to local but not to foreign parasites [8]. In 2011 Levi Morran and colleagues let populations of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, whose hermaphrodites can fertilise themselves or mate with males, coevolve for 30 generations with the bacterium Serratia marcescens, which was selected for infectivity [9]. Outcrossing rose from about 20% to over 70% in the first eight generations with either a fixed or a coevolving pathogen, but stayed high only with the coevolving one, and every obligately self-fertilising population exposed to the coevolving pathogen died out within 20 generations [9].

Linkage and harmful mutations (1974–2016). The argument of Ronald Fisher and Hermann Muller is that sex brings beneficial mutations arising in different individuals together in one lineage [13], relieving the competition between them [11]. Reviewing the controversy in 1974, Felsenstein found that models with finite populations gave recombination an advantage and models with infinite populations gave none: recombination breaks down chance associations between linked genes created by genetic drift, which otherwise make linked genes interfere with each other's response to selection [1]. The same reasoning predicts Muller's ratchet: without recombination, harmful mutations accumulate as the least-loaded class of genomes is lost by chance [1, 4]. In Salmonella grown asexually under high genetic drift, 1% of 444 lineages showed an obvious loss of fitness after 1,700 generations [4]. In 1988 Alexey Kondrashov proposed, as a model, that if the rate of harmful mutation exceeds one per genome per generation, sex may be favoured because selection removes such mutations more efficiently in sexual populations [2]. Peter Keightley and Adam Eyre-Walker estimated this rate across animal species and found it rises with generation time; in species with short generations it is predicted to be "far below 1" [6]. In yeast, Michael McDonald, Daniel Rice and Michael Desai found that sex sped adaptation by reducing competition between beneficial mutations in different clones, and that substantially harmful mutations hitchhiked to fixation in asexual populations but not in sexual ones [11].

Bdelloid rotifers (2000–2026). Over 460 species of these tiny freshwater animals are known, and no males have been reported despite centuries of observation [14]. In 2000 David Mark Welch and Matthew Meselson found highly divergent gene copies within individual genomes, which they read as former alleles diverging since sex was lost [5]; these copies were later found to come from an ancient genome duplication or hybridisation [14]. In 2013 the genome of Adineta vaga appeared to have a structure "incompatible with conventional meiosis" [10]; later long-read and in situ hybridisation data revealed the rearrangements as assembly artefacts and resolved six pairs of homologous chromosomes [14]. Two studies then reported signs of exchange. Olga Vakhrusheva and colleagues found, in 11 wild A. vaga genomes, patterns "incompatible with strict clonality and lack of genetic exchange" [12]; Veronika Laine, Timothy Sackton and Meselson concluded from allele sharing that Macrotrachela quadricornifera is facultatively sexual [13]. In 2024 Christopher Wilson and colleagues wrote that such evidence "requires further validation": both studies analysed less than 10% of the genome, a 2016 report of gene transfer between individuals could be explained by cross-contamination, and recombination within a mother's own germline could produce similar patterns without sex; they also keep open the possibility of rare, undetected males [14]. In September 2026 Antoine Houtain and colleagues reported crossovers and gene conversion in A. vaga lines kept for about 75–135 generations, which they attribute to recombination during a modified meiosis in which paired chromosomes do not separate [15].

Main approaches

Red Queen (coevolving parasites). Parasites adapt to infect common host genotypes, so sex, which produces rare genotypes, is favoured as long as the coevolution continues [3, 9]. Strongest evidence: clone turnover with persistent sexual snails in the field [8], and higher outcrossing and the extinction of self-fertilising worms with coevolving pathogens [9]. Main difficulty: the worm experiment compares outcrossing with self-fertilisation, not with asexual reproduction [9], and the snail authors present parasites as promoting the "short-term coexistence" of sexual and asexual snails [8].

Purging harmful mutations. Sex prevents the accumulation of harmful mutations, by stopping Muller's ratchet in finite populations [1] or, in Kondrashov's model, by removing mutations more efficiently in effectively infinite ones [2, 13]. Strongest evidence: the ratchet reduced fitness in asexual lines of Salmonella, a DNA-based organism with a typical mutation rate; before that it had been shown only in RNA viruses, whose mutation rates are extremely high [4]. Main difficulty: the Salmonella result was obtained under high genetic drift [4]. Kondrashov's version needs more than one harmful mutation per genome per generation, and mutations that interact synergistically, to pay the twofold cost; Keightley and Eyre-Walker's estimates fall far below that rate in species with short generations [6].

Faster adaptation (Fisher–Muller). Recombination brings beneficial mutations together and separates them from harmful ones, so sexual populations adapt faster [1, 11]. Strongest evidence: sequenced experimental yeast populations show both mechanisms at work [11]. Main difficulty: the advantage depends on finite-population effects [1], and the benefit of outcrossing in a new environment "may be short lived" once a population has adapted [9].

Ancient asexuals as a test. A group that has persisted for millions of years without sex would challenge theories of the benefits of sex [13, 14]. Strongest evidence: the continued absence of males in bdelloids [14]. Main difficulty: the genomic evidence has been reinterpreted repeatedly, and the latest studies disagree on whether it shows sex [12, 13, 14].

Open sub-questions

  1. Longer snail records. Over decades rather than 7–10 years, does parasite-driven clone turnover keep the frequency of sexual snails stable in mixed populations [8]?
  2. Sex against asexuality. Does a coevolving pathogen favour sex over asexual reproduction, not only outcrossing over self-fertilisation, in an experimental system with both options [9]?
  3. Synergy where generations are long. In species with long generations, where estimated harmful-mutation rates are highest, do the fitness effects of mutations combine synergistically, as Kondrashov's model requires [2, 6]?
  4. After adaptation. Once yeast populations stop adapting, does the advantage of sex disappear, as the decline of outcrossing in worms facing a fixed pathogen suggests [9, 11]?
  5. Whole-genome allele sharing. Do the allele-sharing patterns in Macrotrachela and Adineta hold when whole chromosome-scale genomes are analysed [12, 13, 14]?
  6. Meiosis without males. Can the crossover and gene-conversion rates measured in laboratory A. vaga lines account for the patterns in wild genomes without outcrossing [12, 15]?

Work on this in Papex

If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.

Key references

  1. Felsenstein, J. (1974). The evolutionary advantage of recombination. Genetics 78(2), 737–756. 10.1093/genetics/78.2.737 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  2. Kondrashov, A. S. (1988). Deleterious mutations and the evolution of sexual reproduction. Nature 336(6198), 435–440. 10.1038/336435a0 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  3. Hamilton, W. D., Axelrod, R. & Tanese, R. (1990). Sexual reproduction as an adaptation to resist parasites (a review). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 87(9), 3566–3573. 10.1073/pnas.87.9.3566 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  4. Andersson, D. I. & Hughes, D. (1996). Muller's ratchet decreases fitness of a DNA-based microbe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93(2), 906–907. 10.1073/pnas.93.2.906 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  5. Mark Welch, D. B. & Meselson, M. (2000). Evidence for the evolution of bdelloid rotifers without sexual reproduction or genetic exchange. Science 288(5469), 1211–1215. 10.1126/science.288.5469.1211 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  6. Keightley, P. D. & Eyre-Walker, A. (2000). Deleterious mutations and the evolution of sex. Science 290(5490), 331–333. 10.1126/science.290.5490.331 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  7. Otto, S. P. & Lenormand, T. (2002). Resolving the paradox of sex and recombination. Nature Reviews Genetics 3(4), 252–261. 10.1038/nrg761 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  8. Jokela, J., Dybdahl, M. F. & Lively, C. M. (2009). The maintenance of sex, clonal dynamics, and host-parasite coevolution in a mixed population of sexual and asexual snails. The American Naturalist 174(S1), S43–S53. 10.1086/599080 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  9. Morran, L. T., Schmidt, O. G., Gelarden, I. A., Parrish, R. C. & Lively, C. M. (2011). Running with the Red Queen: host-parasite coevolution selects for biparental sex. Science 333(6039), 216–218. 10.1126/science.1206360 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  10. Flot, J.-F., Hespeels, B., Li, X., Noel, B., Arkhipova, I., Danchin, E. G. J. et al. (2013). Genomic evidence for ameiotic evolution in the bdelloid rotifer Adineta vaga. Nature 500(7463), 453–457. 10.1038/nature12326 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  11. McDonald, M. J., Rice, D. P. & Desai, M. M. (2016). Sex speeds adaptation by altering the dynamics of molecular evolution. Nature 531(7593), 233–236. 10.1038/nature17143 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  12. Vakhrusheva, O. A., Mnatsakanova, E. A., Galimov, Y. R., Neretina, T. V., Gerasimov, E. S., Naumenko, S. A. et al. (2020). Genomic signatures of recombination in a natural population of the bdelloid rotifer Adineta vaga. Nature Communications 11, 6421. 10.1038/s41467-020-19614-y · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  13. Laine, V. N., Sackton, T. B. & Meselson, M. (2022). Genomic signature of sexual reproduction in the bdelloid rotifer Macrotrachella quadricornifera. Genetics 220(2), iyab221 (published online 2021). 10.1093/genetics/iyab221 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  14. Wilson, C. G., Pieszko, T., Nowell, R. W. & Barraclough, T. G. (2024). Recombination in bdelloid rotifer genomes: asexuality, transfer and stress. Trends in Genetics 40(5), 422–436. 10.1016/j.tig.2024.02.001 · Checked 14 Oct 2026
  15. Houtain, A., Dupré, M. L., Hespeels, B., Nicolas, É., Simion, P., Virgo, J., Heuskin, A.-C., Lenormand, T., Hallet, B. & Van Doninck, K. (2026). Transgenerational chromosome repair in the asexual bdelloid rotifer Adineta vaga. Science Advances 12(37), eaee0891. 10.1126/sciadv.aee0891 · Checked 14 Oct 2026

Page reviewed 14 Oct 2026

Source

Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in biology. Checked 29 Sep 2026.

The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.

Records on this problem

No public record addresses this problem yet.

More in Life sciences