Problem of time
How can the absolute time of quantum mechanics be reconciled with the flexible spacetime of general relativity?
Summary
Why it is open
In standard quantum theory, Chris Isham writes, time "is not a physical observable in the normal sense since it is not represented by an operator. Rather, it is treated as a background parameter" [5]. The conflict becomes sharp when gravity is quantised canonically. In Bryce DeWitt's 1967 formulation, the constraints of general relativity become conditions on the quantum state, and for a finite (spatially closed) universe "these conditions alone govern the dynamics"; the state can depend only on the geometry of space, and "'time' must be determined intrinsically" [1]. The central condition is the Wheeler–DeWitt equation [5]. A state that satisfies the constraints "has no time dependence at all", Isham notes; this "frozen formalism" seemed "to imply that nothing happens in a quantum theory of gravity", and is now understood to reflect the absence of any external time in general relativity, so that time must be measured by variables inside the theory [5]. Karel Kuchař summarised: "the state functional does not seem to depend on time. This hampers the physical interpretation of quantum gravity" [7].
The problem has several parts. Following Kuchař, Isham lists among others the global time problem (an internal time may not be definable everywhere), the multiple-choice problem (different choices of time may give different quantum theories), the Hilbert space problem (no natural positive inner product for solutions of the Wheeler–DeWitt equation) and the problem of functional evolution (quantum anomalies that would make evolution inconsistent) [5]. Edward Anderson's 2012 review distinguishes eight facets [8].
No body sets a bar for a resolution. Kuchař examined "ten major attempts" and discussed their shortcomings [7], and the proposals that work do so in restricted settings [3, 6]. The problem is one obstacle among several to a quantum theory of gravity, covered on the Papex page Quantum gravity.
What is known
Evolution without evolution (1983). Don Page and William Wootters argued that because the time parameter in the Schrödinger equation is not observable, observables "must all commute with the Hamiltonian", so it is consistent with all observations to assume that a closed system such as the universe is in a stationary state; observed change is then a dependence on "internal clock readings" [2]. In this conditional probability interpretation, the state gives probabilities for the rest of a system conditional on the reading of a clock inside it [5].
Objections (1989–1993). William Unruh and Robert Wald proved that in ordinary quantum mechanics with a Hamiltonian bounded from below "no dynamical variable can correlate monotonically" with the Schrödinger time, which counts against letting a dynamical variable play the role of time in the conditional probability interpretation [3]. As Isham reports, Kuchař argued that a working internal clock cannot commute with the constraint and so is not a physical observable, and pressed the scheme's "peculiar lack of any sense of history" [5]; he also argued that it gives the wrong propagators for measurements at two times [10].
Clocks made of matter (1995). J. David Brown and Kuchař coupled gravity to incoherent dust whose particles carry clocks. The Hamiltonian constraint can then be solved for the momentum conjugate to dust time, giving a functional Schrödinger equation with a formally conserved inner product; they called this "as close as one can reasonably expect to a satisfactory phenomenological quantization scheme that is free of most of the problems of time" [6]. They add that "the corresponding problems at the level of vacuum gravity remain, of course, unresolved" [6].
Semiclassical time (1991–2016). Claus Kiefer and Tejinder Singh expanded the Wheeler–DeWitt equation in powers of the gravitational constant and recovered a Schrödinger equation with corrections, some describing "a gravitationally induced violation of unitarity"; the corrections are "numerically extremely tiny except near the big bang and the final stages of a black hole" [4]. Applied to inflation, such corrections change the primordial power spectrum on the largest scales [11]. An earlier calculation that perturbed only the scalar field found a suppression of power; David Brizuela, Kiefer and Manuel Krämer, using gauge-invariant variables, found an enhancement for both scalar and tensor perturbations, with a correction proportional to k⁻³ (k is the wavenumber) that breaks approximate scale invariance [11].
Relational dynamics revisited (2015–2021). Vittorio Giovannetti, Seth Lloyd and Lorenzo Maccone showed that, when measurements are modelled as interactions, the Page–Wootters scheme reproduces "the correct statistics of sequential measurements" [10]. Philipp Höhn, Alexander Smith and Maximilian Lock proved that three relational formalisms, Page–Wootters among them, are equivalent, and argued that Kuchař's criticisms of it are incorrect or resolved [13].
Laboratory illustrations (2014–2017). Ekaterina Moreva and colleagues entangled the polarisations of two photons and used one as a clock: an "internal" observer correlated with the clock photon saw the other photon evolve, while an "external" observer could show that the global state was static [9]. A 2017 version encoded the clock in the position of a single photon and showed a violation of a Leggett–Garg inequality (a test on correlations between measurements at different times) from the internal observer's point of view [12]. No gravity is involved; the authors present the work as showing that the mechanism "can be naturally embedded into (small) subsystems of the universe" [9].
Main approaches
Time before quantisation. Choose a time among the classical variables, or add a matter clock, solve the constraints and then quantise, to obtain a Schrödinger equation [5]. Unimodular gravity can be treated as a special case of a matter clock: the cosmological constant becomes a dynamical variable whose conjugate serves as a cosmological time [5]. Strongest evidence: the dust model [6], and Unruh and Wald's unimodular proposal, which in minisuperspace models (cosmologies reduced to a few variables) "yields a quantum theory with satisfactory interpretive properties" [3]. Main difficulty: the global time and multiple-choice problems [5]; Unruh and Wald judge it "unlikely that this theory will admit sufficiently many observables for general spacetimes" [3], and in Isham's account of Kuchař's analysis the unimodular wave function cannot be read as a probability distribution for the geometry of space [5].
Time from the semiclassical regime. Time is meaningful only approximately: a WKB (semiclassical) expansion of the Wheeler–DeWitt equation yields a Schrödinger equation whose time is extracted from the state itself [5]. Strongest evidence: it recovers ordinary quantum theory with computable corrections [4, 11]. Main difficulty: Unruh and Wald say this interpretation "has only a limited domain of applicability" [3]. In a superposition of semiclassical branches each branch defines its own time, a situation Isham calls "reminiscent of the Schrödinger-cat problem" [5]; see the Papex page Measurement problem. The sign of the predicted inflationary correction has also depended on the choice of solution and variables [11].
Relational time. Time is a correlation between a clock subsystem and the rest of a timeless whole [2, 10]. Strongest evidence: the two-time results and the equivalence of relational formalisms [10, 13], and photon experiments that realise the mechanism in small systems [9, 12]. Main difficulty: the Unruh–Wald theorem that no clock whose Hamiltonian is bounded below can track time monotonically [3], which Höhn and colleagues address with non-ideal clocks described by generalised measurements [13]; and the basic model assumes that interactions between the clock and the rest can be neglected [9].
Open sub-questions
- Interacting clocks. The basic Page–Wootters model neglects interactions between the clock and the rest of the system [9]; how do its conditional probabilities change when they do, and does the equivalence shown by Höhn et al. survive [13]?
- Non-ideal clocks in the laboratory. The photon experiments realised the basic model [9, 12]; can a laboratory experiment with a non-ideal clock test the conditional probabilities and the clock-dependent "temporal nonlocality" effect derived by Höhn et al. [13]?
- Changing clocks. In a minisuperspace model with two candidate clocks, do the quantum theories built on each agree, and can a relational change of clock map one onto the other [5, 13]?
- Sign of the inflationary correction. Which choice of variables and solution fixes the sign of the k⁻³ quantum-gravitational correction to the primordial power spectrum, and what bound do cosmic microwave background data set on it [11]?
- Unitarity-violating terms. Are the unitarity-violating terms of the semiclassical expansion physical, or artefacts of the approximation [4, 11]?
- Unimodular observables. Does unimodular quantum gravity admit enough observables beyond minisuperspace, contrary to Unruh and Wald's expectation [3]?
Work on this in Papex
If you have a testable answer to one of the sub-questions above, you can draft it as a private hypothesis in Papex, or prepare the draft from Claude or ChatGPT with the Papex connector. You review the exact version, sign it and decide whether to publish it; a public record that names this problem is listed on this page. A Papex record shows who signed which version and when. It is not peer review and does not mean the hypothesis is correct.
Key references
- DeWitt, B. S. (1967). Quantum theory of gravity. I. The canonical theory. Physical Review 160(5), 1113–1148. 10.1103/PhysRev.160.1113 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Page, D. N. & Wootters, W. K. (1983). Evolution without evolution: dynamics described by stationary observables. Physical Review D 27(12), 2885–2892. 10.1103/PhysRevD.27.2885 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Unruh, W. G. & Wald, R. M. (1989). Time and the interpretation of canonical quantum gravity. Physical Review D 40(8), 2598–2614. 10.1103/PhysRevD.40.2598 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Kiefer, C. & Singh, T. P. (1991). Quantum gravitational corrections to the functional Schrödinger equation. Physical Review D 44(4), 1067–1076. 10.1103/PhysRevD.44.1067 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Isham, C. J. (1993). Canonical quantum gravity and the problem of time. In L. A. Ibort & M. A. Rodríguez (eds.), Integrable Systems, Quantum Groups, and Quantum Field Theories, NATO ASI Series 409, Springer Netherlands, 157–287. 10.1007/978-94-011-1980-1_6 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Brown, J. D. & Kuchař, K. V. (1995). Dust as a standard of space and time in canonical quantum gravity. Physical Review D 51(10), 5600–5629. 10.1103/PhysRevD.51.5600 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Kuchař, K. V. (2011). Time and interpretations of quantum gravity. International Journal of Modern Physics D 20(Suppl. 1), 3–86. Reprint of a paper first published in the Proceedings of the 4th Canadian Conference on General Relativity and Relativistic Astrophysics, World Scientific (1992), as cited in reference 5. 10.1142/S0218271811019347 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Anderson, E. (2012). Problem of time in quantum gravity. Annalen der Physik 524(12), 757–786. 10.1002/andp.201200147 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Moreva, E., Brida, G., Gramegna, M., Giovannetti, V., Maccone, L. & Genovese, M. (2014). Time from quantum entanglement: an experimental illustration. Physical Review A 89(5), 052122. 10.1103/PhysRevA.89.052122 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Giovannetti, V., Lloyd, S. & Maccone, L. (2015). Quantum time. Physical Review D 92(4), 045033. 10.1103/PhysRevD.92.045033 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Brizuela, D., Kiefer, C. & Krämer, M. (2016). Quantum-gravitational effects on gauge-invariant scalar and tensor perturbations during inflation: the de Sitter case. Physical Review D 93(10), 104035. 10.1103/PhysRevD.93.104035 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Moreva, E., Gramegna, M., Brida, G., Maccone, L. & Genovese, M. (2017). Quantum time: experimental multitime correlations. Physical Review D 96(10), 102005. 10.1103/PhysRevD.96.102005 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
- Höhn, P. A., Smith, A. R. H. & Lock, M. P. E. (2021). Trinity of relational quantum dynamics. Physical Review D 104(6), 066001. 10.1103/PhysRevD.104.066001 · Checked 15 Oct 2026
Source
Open, as listed by Wikipedia · Unsolved problems in physics. Checked 08 Oct 2026.
The status is the source’s. Papex does not decide whether a problem is solved.
Records on this problem
No public record addresses this problem yet.